Re: [Rd] informal conventions/checklist for new predictive modeling packages

2012-01-05 Thread Paul Johnson
I agree with almost all, except the last point. Since I have participated in wheel-reinvention lately, I agree with the bulk of your comment. I don't think the fix is as easy as you suspect, RSiteSearch won't help me find a function I need when I don't know the magic words. Some R functions have s

Re: [Rd] informal conventions/checklist for new predictive modeling packages

2012-01-05 Thread Steve Lianoglou
Good stuff, Max! Would also be nice to nail your 14 theses to a more permanent wall than the r-help mailing list ... not sure where that would be, though ... isn't someone supposed to be redesigning the r-project.org website? [I jest, I jest] More seriously, though, it might be worth linking to fr

Re: [Rd] informal conventions/checklist for new predictive modeling packages

2012-01-05 Thread Liaw, Andy
From: Max Kuhn > > Working on the caret package has exposed me to the wide variety of > approaches that different authors have taken to creating predictive > modeling functions (aka machine learning)(aka pattern recognition). > > I suspect that many package authors are neophyte R users and are >