Re: [Rd] Request for comment: namespace resolution in terms(, specials=) [::, etc.]

2025-04-15 Thread peter dalgaard
I don't seem to have the original post (not in spamfilter either). But generically, I think namespacing specials in formulas is just a Bad Idea. They are syntactic constructs, specifically _not_ function calls, so people are stumbling over formally protecting them from a non-existing scoping iss

Re: [Rd] Request for comment: namespace resolution in terms(, specials=) [::, etc.]

2025-04-14 Thread Ben Bolker
I don't have any concerns about these changes, don't see any need to preserve the old behaviour. In lme4 and glmmTMB (and now broken out into a separate `reformulas` package, I do this the hard way, walking down the parse trees of formula objects and looking for specials, and not using the