Re: tarfile vs zipfile

2015-03-03 Thread Marcos Almeida Azevedo
On Tue, Mar 3, 2015 at 6:39 PM, Gregory Ewing wrote: > Mark Lawrence wrote: > >> On 03/03/2015 02:29, Terry Reedy wrote: >> >> Plus tartfiles come from unix world, whereas zip was used instead in >>> Windows world. >>> >>> Is the tart bit the thing that you can eat, a loose woman or something >

Re: tarfile vs zipfile

2015-03-03 Thread Gregory Ewing
Mark Lawrence wrote: On 03/03/2015 02:29, Terry Reedy wrote: Plus tartfiles come from unix world, whereas zip was used instead in Windows world. Is the tart bit the thing that you can eat, a loose woman or something else, such as a typo? :) Tartfiles would be what you get from xxx sites, no

Re: tarfile vs zipfile

2015-03-02 Thread Mark Lawrence
On 03/03/2015 02:29, Terry Reedy wrote: On 3/2/2015 8:12 PM, Ben Finney wrote: Seth P writes: Is there a reason tarfile and zipfile don't use the same method/member names, where it makes sense? The situation is known to some core developers, but is hard to change now. One likely explanati

Re: tarfile vs zipfile

2015-03-02 Thread Gregory Ewing
Seth P wrote: Is there a reason tarfile and zipfile don't use the same method/member names, where it makes sense? There was talk in the python-dev mailing list recently about creating a unified interface to the various archiving modules. You might like to keep an eye on what's happening there.

Re: tarfile vs zipfile

2015-03-02 Thread Terry Reedy
On 3/2/2015 8:12 PM, Ben Finney wrote: Seth P writes: Is there a reason tarfile and zipfile don't use the same method/member names, where it makes sense? The situation is known to some core developers, but is hard to change now. One likely explanation is that the modules's APIs were design

Re: tarfile vs zipfile

2015-03-02 Thread Ben Finney
Seth P writes: > Is there a reason tarfile and zipfile don't use the same method/member > names, where it makes sense? One likely explanation is that the modules's APIs were designed by different people unaware of the work of the other. -- \“We have to go forth and crush every world v

tarfile vs zipfile

2015-03-02 Thread Seth P
Is there a reason tarfile and zipfile don't use the same method/member names, where it makes sense? Consider the following six methods/members, which I would expect to be the same (with the possible exception of mtime vs date_time, which are of different types). It almost seems like someone we