Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-19 Thread Nobody
On Thu, 18 Oct 2012 14:44:27 +0100, andrea crotti wrote: > Uhh I see thanks, I guess I'll use the good-old .lock file (even if it > might have some problems too). In which case, you don't see. A lock file is also advisory, i.e. it only affects applications which explicitly check for a lock file.

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-19 Thread andrea crotti
2012/10/18 Oscar Benjamin : > > The lock is cooperative. It does not prevent the file from being > opened or overwritten. It only prevents any other process from > obtaining the lock. Here you open the file with mode 'w' which > truncates the file instantly (without checking for the lock). > > > Os

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-18 Thread Oscar Benjamin
On 18 October 2012 16:08, andrea crotti wrote: > 2012/10/18 Oscar Benjamin : >> >> Why not come up with a test that actually shows you if it works? Here >> are two suggestions: >> >> 1) Use time.sleep() so that you know how long the lock is held for. >> 2) Write different data into the file from e

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-18 Thread andrea crotti
2012/10/18 Oscar Benjamin : > > Why not come up with a test that actually shows you if it works? Here > are two suggestions: > > 1) Use time.sleep() so that you know how long the lock is held for. > 2) Write different data into the file from each process and see what > you end up with. > Ok thank

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-18 Thread Oscar Benjamin
On 18 October 2012 15:49, andrea crotti wrote: > 2012/10/18 Grant Edwards : >> >> If what you're guarding against is multiple instances of your >> application modifying the file, then either of the advisory file >> locking schemes or the separate lock file should work fine. > > Ok so I tried a sma

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-18 Thread Grant Edwards
On 2012-10-18, andrea crotti wrote: > 2012/10/18 Grant Edwards : >> On 2012-10-18, andrea crotti wrote: >> >> File locks under Unix have historically been "advisory". That means >> that programs have to _choose_ to pay attention to them. Most >> programs do not. >> >> Linux does support mandato

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-18 Thread Oscar Benjamin
On 18 October 2012 14:44, andrea crotti wrote: > 2012/10/18 Grant Edwards : >> On 2012-10-18, andrea crotti wrote: >> >> >> File locks under Unix have historically been "advisory". That means >> that programs have to _choose_ to pay attention to them. Most >> programs do not. >> >> Linux does s

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-18 Thread andrea crotti
2012/10/18 Grant Edwards : > On 2012-10-18, andrea crotti wrote: > > > File locks under Unix have historically been "advisory". That means > that programs have to _choose_ to pay attention to them. Most > programs do not. > > Linux does support mandatory locking, but it's rarely used and must be

Re: locking files on Linux

2012-10-18 Thread Grant Edwards
On 2012-10-18, andrea crotti wrote: > I'm trying to understand how I can lock a file while writing on it, > because I might have multiple processes working on it at the same time. > > I found the fcntl.lockf function but if I do this: > > In [109]: locked = open('locked.txt', 'w') > > In [110]: f