Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-12 Thread Justin Zygmont
you might have to make a new initrd and set grub to point to that. On Wed, 12 Mar 2003, Margaret_Doll wrote: > I am missing something with the data=writeback option in /etc/fstab > I put that in place of the "defaults" for the system disk partitions > and now > only / gets mounted and it is in

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-12 Thread Margaret_Doll
I am missing something with the data=writeback option in /etc/fstab I put that in place of the "defaults" for the system disk partitions and now only / gets mounted and it is in a read-only mode. On Monday, March 10, 2003, at 10:58 PM, Justin Zygmont wrote: I never noticed any difference. Try

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-11 Thread Javier Gostling
On Mon, 2003-03-10 at 23:01, JD wrote: > Hallo list, > I have a "feeling" that ext3 is much slower than ext2. My hadrdrive > blinks more often after I let RH8 formatted it with its favorite ext3; > not to mention the noise from the harddrive rotation. > As I said, it's just a "feeling" so please

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-11 Thread Justin Zygmont
> ext2 distro on there now. Honestly, I can't really tell a difference > between ext2 and ext3, but my laptop is fairly new (2 Ghz P4). I like > having the extra protection of ext3/reiserfs. and I have a fairly slow computer (p-200) and I can't even tell the difference. There should be very

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-11 Thread Keith Winston
JD wrote: Make sense! I'm always a linux laptop user [this time is on vaio]. That "slower" feeling comes because, like if I fire up the konsole then it takes a second or two before the prompt shows up. Firing up other apps is also the same, it always makes the HD seem to work extra harder. In th

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-11 Thread Tom Ball
I found ext3 much slower on my laptop when it was first installed. However, after adding "data=writeback" to the /etc/fstab settings for /, my system is now "fast enough". Tom On Mon, 2003-03-10 at 19:01, JD wrote: > Hallo list, > I have a "feeling" that ext3 is much slower than ext2. My hadr

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-11 Thread JD
Michael Stack wrote: I recently read an interview w/ one of the maintainers of ext3, and they mentioned that it generates quite a bit more drive activity than ext2. For that reason, they recommended against using ext3 for laptops. As to whether it's slower or not, I have to imagine that the journa

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-11 Thread Michael Schwendt
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On Tue, 11 Mar 2003 09:22:14 +0200, Jason Dale wrote: > Ext3 came into the picture from around RH 7.2, and it comes with some > Journaling features designed to make your file system recover from crashes > better than ext2 did. > > Because of this jo

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-10 Thread Jason Dale
Hi There! Ext3 came into the picture from around RH 7.2, and it comes with some Journaling features designed to make your file system recover from crashes better than ext2 did. Because of this journaling, there will be a performance decrease, which is probably what you are experiencing. Jason D

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-10 Thread Justin Zygmont
I never noticed any difference. Try adding data=writeback to the appropriate place in the fstab and see if that helps... On Mon, 10 Mar 2003, JD wrote: > Hallo list, > I have a "feeling" that ext3 is much slower than ext2. My hadrdrive > blinks more often after I let RH8 formatted it with it

Re: Ext3 vs Ext2

2003-03-10 Thread Michael Stack
I recently read an interview w/ one of the maintainers of ext3, and they mentioned that it generates quite a bit more drive activity than ext2. For that reason, they recommended against using ext3 for laptops. As to whether it's slower or not, I have to imagine that the journaling has some overhead