Re: DKIM verification vith virtual domains in same machine

2014-02-04 Thread Solk Maaker
use 127.0.0.0/8 range for signers, and for wan only do verifying, this only need opendkim-verify.conf and opendkim-signer.conf with is binded in master.cf as services where it fit For some reason second postfix refused to route mail out to wan ip (loops back to myself) when i binded it only to

Re: DKIM verification vith virtual domains in same machine

2014-02-03 Thread Benny Pedersen
On 2014-02-04 07:53, Solk Maaker wrote: Only downside is that this setup needs two ip addresses. use 127.0.0.0/8 range for signers, and for wan only do verifying, this only need opendkim-verify.conf and opendkim-signer.conf with is binded in master.cf as services where it fit

Re: DKIM verification vith virtual domains in same machine

2014-02-03 Thread Solk Maaker
You can do both on one machine using multiple postfix instances, one for incoming mail and another for outgoing mail, each running on its own IP. But since you already have multiple postfix instances on two machines it seems silly to complicate a working setup for little gain, unless you're tryin

Re: DKIM verification vith virtual domains in same machine

2014-02-03 Thread Noel Jones
On 2/3/2014 5:31 AM, Solk Maaker wrote: >> From DKIM's perspective it really makes no sense to validate a >> signature generated by yourself. >> ( How often do you check your own identity card to prove that you >> are you? ) > > Yes, that is true, there is no point to verify my own signature, but

Re: DKIM verification vith virtual domains in same machine

2014-02-03 Thread Solk Maaker
From DKIM's perspective it really makes no sense to validate a signature generated by yourself. ( How often do you check your own identity card to prove that you are you? ) Yes, that is true, there is no point to verify my own signature, but in case of virtual domains, if domain1 does not belo

Re: DKIM verification vith virtual domains in same machine

2014-02-03 Thread Andreas Schulze
Solk Maaker: If user sends mail from domain1 (virtual domain) to domain2 (virtual domain) in same machine, mail is signed but signature is not verified - not OK. From DKIM's perspective it really makes no sense to validate a signature generated by yourself. ( How often do you check you

DKIM verification vith virtual domains in same machine

2014-02-03 Thread Solk Maaker
Hi Problem description: If user sends mail out (to Internet) from domain1 (virtual domain), mail is signed and in receiver side mail is verified - everything is OK. If mail comes in (from Internet) to domain1 (virtual domain) wiht DKIM signature, signature is verified - everything is OK. If use