Re: Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-23 Thread LuKreme
On Jan 23, 2018, at 03:04, Peter wrote: > I would still use Dovecot for the server side and just install those very few > libs that are necessary from Cyrus for the client SASL support. Agree. After switching to dovecot years ago I'm never going back to Cyrus. -- This is my signature. There a

Re: Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-23 Thread Peter
On 20/01/18 19:32, Bill Cole wrote: > If you need *outbound* SASL support (i.e. authentication to an upstream > relay) then You can choose Cyrus or nothing. A point of clarification for outbound Cyrus SASL: For this Postfix simply has to have been built against the Cyrus SASL libraries and you on

Re: Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-19 Thread Bill Cole
On 16 Jan 2018, at 17:19 (-0500), J Doe wrote: Hi, I am looking to use either Cyrus or Dovecot for both SASL authentication and IMAP. While Postfix 3.1.0 supports both, I was wondering which to prefer if security is my most important deciding factor ? Does one have a better track record th

Re: Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-17 Thread The Doctor
On Wed, Jan 17, 2018 at 06:26:52AM +0100, Patrick Ben Koetter wrote: > * J Doe : > > I am looking to use either Cyrus or Dovecot for both SASL authentication and > > IMAP. While Postfix 3.1.0 supports both, I was wondering which to prefer if > > security is my most important deciding factor ? Doe

Re: Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-17 Thread Larry Stone
> On Jan 16, 2018, at 11:26 PM, Patrick Ben Koetter wrote: > > The Cyrus SASL project has been discontinued. I recommend not to use security > relevant software that is unmaintained. Use Dovecot as password verification > service for Postfix. There seems to still be activity. I am subscribed t

Re: Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-16 Thread Patrick Ben Koetter
* J Doe : > I am looking to use either Cyrus or Dovecot for both SASL authentication and > IMAP. While Postfix 3.1.0 supports both, I was wondering which to prefer if > security is my most important deciding factor ? Does one have a better > track record than the other ? The Cyrus SASL project h

Re: Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-16 Thread Petri Riihikallio
> I am looking to use either Cyrus or Dovecot for both SASL authentication and > IMAP. While Postfix 3.1.0 supports both, I was wondering which to prefer if > security is my most important deciding factor ? Does one have a better track > record than the other ? They are both quite secure, I c

Cyrus vs Dovecot for SASL AUTH and IMAP

2018-01-16 Thread J Doe
Hi, I am looking to use either Cyrus or Dovecot for both SASL authentication and IMAP. While Postfix 3.1.0 supports both, I was wondering which to prefer if security is my most important deciding factor ? Does one have a better track record than the other ? Thanks, - J