Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-07 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
real world. That said, I always think relationally when designing databases - it helps. Look at the multi-value databases. Think relationally, you can still store your data in normal form, but you're not stuffed by all the irrelevant restrictions that relational databases tend to impose.

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-07 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
>elegance and mathematical principles. Mathematical principles? You mean like Euclidean Geometry and Newtonian Mechanics? They're perfectly solid, good, mathematically correct. Shame they don't actually WORK all the time in the real world. That's what I feel about relational, too ... C

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-17 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
teach to everyone else, and the end result is that all research is ploughed into a model that may be (I didn't say "is") bankrupt. Just like the academics were brainwashed into thinking that microkernels were the be-all and end-all - until Linus showed them by practical example that

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-21 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
in memory. Pick optimises the hard task of getting it into memory in the first place". "Relational" is all about theory and proving things mathematically correct. "MV" is all about engineering and getting the result. And if that means pinching all the best ideas we can find fr

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-23 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Lauri Pietarinen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes >Anthony W. Youngman wrote: > >> >>Fine. But MV *doesn't* *need* much of a cache. Let's assume both SQL and >>MV have the same amount of RAM to cache in - i.e. *not* *muc

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-24 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
didn't say relational is *incorrect* - the ideas of "mathematically correct" and "scientifically provable" are orthogonal, and have nothing to say about each other. Cheers, Wol -- Anthony W. Youngman - wol at thewolery dot demon dot co dot uk Witches are curious by definit

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-24 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Lauri Pietarinen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes >Anthony W. Youngman wrote: > >>Well, as far as we MV'ers are concerned, performance IS a problem with >>the relational approach. The attitude (as far as I can tell) with &g

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-24 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
d they were to beat this MV system! Yet with hardware that was so much more powerful and a query that was heavily optimised, they had great difficulty beating a query that was thrown together in seconds by an average MV guy (or even just a luser!). Don't forget. I said I am a database *engi

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-27 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Anthony W. Youngman <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes >>Really, however you calculate it, it is an order of magnitude less >>than your alternative. >> >>And please don't tell me that using indexes is not fair or not in the >&

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-27 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
d about is that there is room for about 5% improvement before we hit that mathematical limit. SQL has a HELL of a long way to go to catch up :-) Cheers, Wol -- Anthony W. Youngman - wol at thewolery dot demon dot co dot uk Witches are curious by definition and inquisitive by nature. She moved in

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-10-27 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Lauri Pietarinen writes >Anthony W. Youngman wrote: > >>In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Lauri Pietarinen >><[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes >> >> >>>Anthony W. Youngman wrote: >>> >>> >&

Re: [HACKERS] Dreaming About Redesigning SQL

2003-11-09 Thread Anthony W. Youngman
In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Lauri Pietarinen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes >Anthony W. Youngman wrote: >>In article <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Lauri Pietarinen >[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes >>>Anthony W. Youngman wrote: >>>>In article <[EMAIL PRO