Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-06-03 Thread Lew
Francisco Reyes wrote: Lew writes: Strange? Why? Did you expect a particular statistical distribution? Perhaps The impression was that one query was returning everything.. and the other only the records that did not exist in the one table. you were surprised by the extent of the situa

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-29 Thread Francisco Reyes
Lew writes: Strange? Why? Did you expect a particular statistical distribution? Perhaps The impression was that one query was returning everything.. and the other only the records that did not exist in the one table. you were surprised by the extent of the situation, not thinking there

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-28 Thread Lew
Your top-posting was confusing to me, but I eventually figured out what went where. Francisco Reyes wrote: However.. I find it very strange that just the selects by themselves produced the same ouput up to limit 100. Strange? Why? Did you expect a particular statistical distribution? Perha

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-26 Thread Francisco Reyes
Scott Marlowe writes: Note that if you're in a transaction, you don't technically need the backup (doesn't hurt though) as if you get it wrong you can just roll it back. I know.. I do the backup in case I forget to do the transaction. :-) ---(end of broadcast)---

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-25 Thread Scott Marlowe
Francisco Reyes wrote: Alban Hertroys writes: I suppose you run those queries in a transaction block, right? Correct. Also I do a backup before doing the deletions. Note that if you're in a transaction, you don't technically need the backup (doesn't hurt though) as if you get it wrong you

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-24 Thread Francisco Reyes
Alban Hertroys writes: Why not use EXISTS? DELETE FROM export_messages WHERE NOT EXISTS ( SELECT 1 FROM exports WHERE exports.export_id = export_messages.export_id ) Didn't think of it. Thanks for the code. I suppose you run those queries in a transaction block, r

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-24 Thread Alban Hertroys
Francisco Reyes wrote: > When I try to run: > delete from export_messages where export_id in > (SELECT distinct export_messages.export_id as id > FROM export_messages > LEFT OUTER JOIN exports ON (export_messages.export_id = exports.export_id) > ); Why not use EXISTS? DELETE FROM export_messages

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-23 Thread Francisco Reyes
Joris Dobbelsteen writes: Try this: SELECT distinct export_messages.export_id as id, exports.export_id as exports_export_id FROM export_messages LEFT OUTER JOIN exports ON (export_messages.export_id = exports.export_id) WHERE exports.export_id IS NOT NULL; In my case I needed "IS NULL" Y

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-23 Thread Francisco Reyes
Joris Dobbelsteen writes: Did you really check your list thoroughly. SELECT distinct export_messages.export_id as id FROM export_messages LEFT OUTER JOIN exports ON (export_messages.export_id = exports.export_id); Take any value from "SELECT export_id FROM exports" Does it not exist in you

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-23 Thread Joris Dobbelsteen
>-Original Message- >From: Francisco Reyes [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] >Sent: donderdag 24 mei 2007 2:04 >To: Joris Dobbelsteen >Cc: PostgreSQL general >Subject: Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records > >Joris Dobbelsteen writes: > >>

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-23 Thread Francisco Reyes
Joris Dobbelsteen writes: Hint: LEFT JOIN is your mistake... The use of left join in general.. or my left join? When I do the left join by itself I verified manually and it had the data I wanted. Thought: are you sure you are going to delete those rows? In there cases human verification is

Re: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-23 Thread Joris Dobbelsteen
Behalf Of >Francisco Reyes >Sent: donderdag 24 mei 2007 1:12 >To: PostgreSQL general >Subject: [GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records > >I have two tables >exports >export_messages > >They were done without a foreign key and I am trying to clean >the data t

[GENERAL] Delete with subquery deleting all records

2007-05-23 Thread Francisco Reyes
I have two tables exports export_messages They were done without a foreign key and I am trying to clean the data to put a constraint. For every record in exports_messages there is supposed to be a matching record in exports with a export_id (ie export_id is the foreign key for export_message