Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-09 Thread Dan Sugalski
At 4:40 PM +0200 8/9/04, Paolo Molaro wrote: If people are interested, we might be able to cooperate to develop a library which does just that (unicode string collation) and which could be imported and used both in mono and parrot (with minimal or no changes). From the mono point of view, the licen

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-09 Thread Paolo Molaro
On 08/03/04 Leon Brocard wrote: > IIRC the mono people wrote their own, but with the ICU data files. > Apart from license issues, this might be an interesting thing to look > at. We use some of the ICU data files for locale info like day/month names, date/time formats etc. We have a tool that take

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Nicholas Clark
On Tue, Aug 03, 2004 at 11:32:33PM +0100, Alex Gough wrote: > For what it's worth, I checked a parrot out for the first time in ages > a couple of days ago (the Shub-tuit gives, as the Shub-tuit takes > away...), but got all stuck failing to work out how to get icu not to > be a problem, and so get

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Brent 'Dax' Royal-Gordon
Josh Wilmes wrote: If someone's got the time and I spec out the encoding and charset APIs, I'd be thrilled if ICU became optional again. Wouldn't hurt my feelings at all. We need it, because we need Unicode, but it doesn't have to be required. We'll need something that isn't ICU if we're going t

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Josh Wilmes
At 18:46 on 08/03/2004 EDT, Dan Sugalski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > If someone's got the time and I spec out the encoding and charset > APIs, I'd be thrilled if ICU became optional again. Wouldn't hurt my > feelings at all. We need it, because we need Unicode, but it doesn't > have to be req

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Dan Sugalski
At 7:22 PM +0100 8/3/04, Alberto Manuel Brandao Simoes wrote: Although I sent this ideas to this list, with another subject, here they go again to enter in the correct thread. I think that to have ICU included both in CVS and tarballs created for parrot is not the best way. I know Dan (and maybe

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Alberto Manuel Brandao Simoes
Although I sent this ideas to this list, with another subject, here they go again to enter in the correct thread. I think that to have ICU included both in CVS and tarballs created for parrot is not the best way. I know Dan (and maybe some others) do not want to depend on too much libraries. Th

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Alex Gough
[Tue, Aug 03, 2004 at 07:45:57PM +0100: Nicholas Clark] > On Tue, Aug 03, 2004 at 03:09:02PM +0100, Leon Brocard wrote: > > Dan Sugalski sent the following bits through the ether: > > > > > If someone's tempted to do 3) Write our own Unicode system, I'm OK > > > with that too. The string int

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Nicholas Clark
On Tue, Aug 03, 2004 at 03:09:02PM +0100, Leon Brocard wrote: > Dan Sugalski sent the following bits through the ether: > > > If someone's tempted to do 3) Write our own Unicode system, I'm OK > > with that too. The string internals doc needs writing, and I can get > > that done. > > IIRC the m

RE: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Garrett Goebel
Joshua Gatcomb wrote: > Dan Sugalski wrote: > > ... and therefore ICU will continue to stay in CVS as part of > > parrot. Period. > > > > The alternative here is the same alternative as with GMP and big > > numbers--we can yank ICU *if* someone writes an alternate Unicode > > implementation for

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Leon Brocard
Dan Sugalski sent the following bits through the ether: > If someone's tempted to do 3) Write our own Unicode system, I'm OK > with that too. The string internals doc needs writing, and I can get > that done. IIRC the mono people wrote their own, but with the ICU data files. Apart from license

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Dan Sugalski
At 6:20 AM -0700 8/3/04, Joshua Gatcomb wrote: --- Dan Sugalski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: ... and therefore ICU will continue to stay in CVS as part of parrot. Period. The alternative here is the same alternative as with GMP and big numbers--we can yank ICU *if* someone writes an alternate Un

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Joshua Gatcomb
--- Dan Sugalski <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > ... and therefore ICU will continue to stay in CVS > as part of parrot. Period. > > The alternative here is the same alternative as with > GMP and big numbers--we can yank ICU *if* someone > writes an alternate Unicode implementation for us. > -- >

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-03 Thread Dan Sugalski
At 9:58 AM +0200 8/1/04, Leopold Toetsch wrote: Jerry Gay <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Leopold Toetch wrote: Both ways - or better three stages: Its optional. If its there, we *can* link against it. If you want/need it, and your OS doesn't have it, well, then install it. and if you don't want

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-08-01 Thread Leopold Toetsch
Jerry Gay <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Leopold Toetch wrote: >> Both ways - or better three stages: Its optional. If its >> there, we *can* link against it. If you want/need it, and >> your OS doesn't have it, well, then install it. >> > and if you don't want it you get... what? > no unicode supp

RE: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-07-31 Thread Gay, Jerry
Leopold Toetch wrote: > Both ways - or better three stages: Its optional. If its > there, we *can* link against it. If you want/need it, and > your OS doesn't have it, well, then install it. > and if you don't want it you get... what? no unicode support? a hand-rolled solution? just what is th

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-07-31 Thread Leopold Toetsch
Joshua Gatcomb wrote: For some reason (likely because it was friday), what I was thinking in my head was not what was coming out on the screen in front of me. The "make ICU optional" was supposed to read "make ICU like GMP" - autodetect it if present, but do not force it upon the user. Both ways -

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-07-31 Thread Joshua Gatcomb
--- Leopold Toetsch <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Joshua Gatcomb <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > All: > > The ICU that is bundled with Parrot is old. > > > George Rhoten, an ICU developer, has suggested we > > start shipping version 3.0 because: > > > B. Make ICU optional. > > Yes. And I'll vot

Re: ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-07-30 Thread Leopold Toetsch
Joshua Gatcomb <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > All: > The ICU that is bundled with Parrot is old. > George Rhoten, an ICU developer, has suggested we > start shipping version 3.0 because: > B. Make ICU optional. Yes. And I'll vote for just tossing icu/* from Parrot CVS. If one wants to build Parro

ICU Outdated - Ideas

2004-07-30 Thread Joshua Gatcomb
All: The ICU that is bundled with Parrot is old. Normally that wouldn't be a problem if you didn't require all the features and bug fixes with a newer version, but we are still having problems with ICU and are even supplying patches for it. I went through a personal nightmare of getting it to wor