Re: [openssl-users] SSL Cert serial number non-uniqueness impact

2018-01-16 Thread Kyle Hamilton
It's important to note that NSS-based applications (such as Firefox) will actually categorically refuse to connect to a site with an Issuer/serial collision with another certificate it has seen before. So yes, it can cause some applications to fail their SSL connections. -Kyle H On Tue, Jan 16,

Re: [openssl-users] SSL Cert serial number non-uniqueness impact

2018-01-16 Thread Wouter Verhelst
On 14/01/2018 12:07, pratyush parimal wrote: > Hi everyone, > > I read  from several sources that the serial number of a cert MUST be > unique within a CA. But could someone explain what would happen if the > serial number was not unique? The certificate itself will continue to work (the signature

Re: [openssl-users] SSL Cert serial number non-uniqueness impact

2018-01-14 Thread Salz, Rich via openssl-users
The combination of (issuer,serial#) is the only way to get a unique identifier for a certificate. Lots of software depends on certs being uniquely identifiable. What happens if that assertion is not true? Some things will break. What? Well, it depends on the software, and which certs are “

Re: [openssl-users] SSL Cert serial number non-uniqueness impact

2018-01-14 Thread Jochen Bern
On 01/14/2018 12:07 PM, pratyush parimal wrote: > I read from several sources that the serial number of a cert MUST be > unique within a CA. But could someone explain what would happen if the > serial number was not unique? Certificate Revocation Lists (CRLs) identify invalid certificates by mean

[openssl-users] SSL Cert serial number non-uniqueness impact

2018-01-14 Thread pratyush parimal
Hi everyone, I read from several sources that the serial number of a cert MUST be unique within a CA. But could someone explain what would happen if the serial number was not unique? Would it cause SSL connections to fail in some manner? I think I'm a little unclear about the "purpose" of the se