Re: [OAUTH-WG] Requesting mutliple scope, but user authorizes not all

2010-12-01 Thread Justin Richer
Just as a matter of clarification about the downscope language in the spec: The downscoping capability here is intended mostly for getting special-use tokens, for things like redelegation to other apps. So say I grant access to AppA with scope "read write", and AppA gets a refresh and access token

Re: [OAUTH-WG] Requesting mutliple scope, but user authorizes not all

2010-12-01 Thread David Primmer
As Eran pointed out, the way you've formatted your scope request, you've only specified one scope and I'd guess to keep things simple and consistent can either be approved or denied. I don't have a spec reference about what happens when the user doesn't approve but I assume the response is sent to

Re: [OAUTH-WG] Requesting mutliple scope, but user authorizes not all

2010-11-30 Thread Igor Faynberg
Nat Sakimura wrote: I think such things are better dealt with extensions. Sure. But first we need to define that which we will later extend. I do not like to overload "scope". Neither do I, as long as "overloading" means varying the original semantics. But, again, at the moment we h

Re: [OAUTH-WG] Requesting mutliple scope, but user authorizes not all

2010-11-28 Thread Nat Sakimura
I think such things are better dealt with extensions. I do not like to overload "scope". =nat On Sat, Nov 27, 2010 at 5:26 AM, Igor Faynberg wrote: > In the context of Martin's question (which concerns end-users understanding > and resulting actions), I interpret the citation as follows: The en

Re: [OAUTH-WG] Requesting mutliple scope, but user authorizes not all

2010-11-26 Thread Igor Faynberg
In the context of Martin's question (which concerns end-users understanding and resulting actions), I interpret the citation as follows: The end-user has no control over the value of the "scope" parameter, and, given that "it is defined by the authorization server," the end-user is not expected

Re: [OAUTH-WG] Requesting mutliple scope, but user authorizes not all

2010-11-26 Thread Eran Hammer-Lahav
-10 4.2: scope OPTIONAL. The scope of the access token as a list of space- delimited strings. The value of the "scope" parameter is defined by the authorization server. If the value contains multiple space-delimited strings, their order does not matter,