Re: [OAUTH-WG] Adding the option to use server-supplied nonces to DPoP

2021-09-17 Thread Brian Campbell
Hey Mike, thanks for writing up the PR. Generally speaking, I think it nicely and fairly unobtrusively introduces the ability for servers to choose whether/when to use server-contributed nonces to further constrain lifetimes of DPoP proof. I've been reluctant to add something like this out of conc

Re: [OAUTH-WG] Adding the option to use server-supplied nonces to DPoP

2021-09-17 Thread Justin Richer
Hi Mike, thanks for this writeup and bringing this attack surface to the attention of the group! I would like to also discuss how this attack and solution could be applied to the proposed HTTP Message Signatures based draft for OAuth 2: https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-richer-oauth-httpsig

[OAUTH-WG] Adding the option to use server-supplied nonces to DPoP

2021-09-17 Thread Mike Jones
We all know that using proof-of-possession with issued tokens is a means of rendering exfiltrated tokens useless to attackers. The DPoP was created as one of the tools to prevent this. There's a huge amount of evidence of successful token exfiltration attacks in the wild, some of which is refe