Re: Large BGP Communities beacon in the wild

2016-11-02 Thread Mark Tinka
On 27/Oct/16 08:19, Job Snijders wrote: > Please verify if you can see 192.147.168.0/24 and 2001:67c:208c::/48 Looks good for me. Both come with: unknown transitive attribute: flag 0xE0 type 0x20 length 0xC value 3CCA 0001 0001 Mark.

Re: Large BGP Communities beacon in the wild

2016-10-28 Thread Randy Bush
> read the IDR thread(1), the vendors in question actually self reported. > I don't think 'shame' here is quite appropriate, but certainly owen's note > about: "Hey, pls don't do this again" with the added: ""this is not a good > path to continue" were noted by several folks on the IDR list. lucki

Re: Large BGP Communities beacon in the wild

2016-10-27 Thread Christopher Morrow
On Thu, Oct 27, 2016 at 5:28 PM, James Bensley wrote: > > > Name and shame, it is not acceptable! > > read the IDR thread(1), the vendors in question actually self reported. I don't think 'shame' here is quite appropriate, but certainly owen's note about: "Hey, pls don't do this again" with the a

Re: Large BGP Communities beacon in the wild

2016-10-27 Thread James Bensley
On 27 October 2016 at 16:47, Owen DeLong wrote: > I don’t mind the move to 32, but I hope the vendors are getting appropriately > smacked for squatting and that those attributes are not allowed to be > misappropriated by the vendors. > > We have a standards process for a reason and vendors simpl

Re: Large BGP Communities beacon in the wild

2016-10-27 Thread Owen DeLong
I don’t mind the move to 32, but I hope the vendors are getting appropriately smacked for squatting and that those attributes are not allowed to be misappropriated by the vendors. We have a standards process for a reason and vendors simply squatting on numbers is a violation of that process whi

Re: Large BGP Communities beacon in the wild

2016-10-26 Thread Job Snijders
Dear Internet, Through this beacon it was discovered that a vendor was squatting on BGP Path Attribute value 30. And another vendor sat on 31. So, a twisted turn of events, the Large BGP Communities effort has ended up with BGP Path Attribute value 32 - very befitting if you look at the very prob

Re: Large BGP Communities beacon in the wild

2016-10-11 Thread Baldur Norddahl
Hi This looks like this on the ZTE M6000 platform: ballerup-edge1#show bgp vpnv4 unicast vrf internet detail 192.147.168.0 255.255.255.0 BGP routing table entry for 192.147.168.0/24 25w4d received from 149.6.136.169 (154.26.32.23), path-id 0 Origin i, nexthop 149.6.136.169, metric 100, loca