RE: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-10 Thread Miya Kohno
> I would be interested to know what your views on this are with your vendor hat on :) Business case conciliates resource contentions... :)

RE: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-10 Thread David Freedman
ple should they choose to implement it. I would be interested to know what your views on this are with your vendor hat on :) Dave. > -Original Message- > From: Mark Tinka [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Sent: Monday, November 10, 2008 10:46 AM > To: nanog@nanog.org > Cc: David Fr

RE: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-09 Thread Miya Kohno
Hi Julien, > > If we consider the phases in terms of IPv6 deployment, > > > > Ph-0: IPv4 only > > Ph-1: IPv4/v6 dual stack + v4/v6 coexistence technologies > > Ph-2: IPv6 only > > Hmm, not quite. I'd say: > > v4 only > v4/v6 dual stack, with v4 being primary (for network > management, r

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-09 Thread Julien Goodwin
On 10/11/08 17:36, Miya Kohno wrote: > > > If we consider the phases in terms of IPv6 deployment, > > Ph-0: IPv4 only > Ph-1: IPv4/v6 dual stack + v4/v6 coexistence technologies > Ph-2: IPv6 only Hmm, not quite. I'd say: v4 only v4/v6 dual stack, with v4 being primary (for network mana

RE: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-09 Thread Miya Kohno
6 AM > To: nanog@nanog.org > Cc: David Freedman > Subject: Re: MPLS for IPv6 > > On Friday 07 November 2008 17:22:33 David Freedman wrote: > > > So please, if you are spending your hard earned cash, > please ask for > > an LDP6 implementation, "no demand" s

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-09 Thread Mark Tinka
On Friday 07 November 2008 17:22:33 David Freedman wrote: > So please, if you are spending your hard earned cash, > please ask for an LDP6 implementation, "no demand" should > not be the case. I sent our SE's at C & J yet another reminder about this. Mark. signature.asc Description: This is a

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-07 Thread David Freedman
Well, don't know about anybody else, but I've been asking vendors for LDP6 for a while now, every time we approach them for new projects and they always look embarrassed when they realise that they a. don't have it b. are not involved in the standards process (draft-manral-mpls-ldp-ipv6-02) So p

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-04 Thread Nathan Ward
On 5/11/2008, at 11:36 AM, Daniel Roesen wrote: On Tue, Nov 04, 2008 at 02:53:46PM -0600, devang patel wrote: Does any vendor support the MPLS for native IPv6 network? Unfortunately noone of the major vendors have yet implemented MPLS control plane via IPv6 transport. From my understanding, t

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-04 Thread Daniel Roesen
On Tue, Nov 04, 2008 at 02:53:46PM -0600, devang patel wrote: > Does any vendor support the MPLS for native IPv6 network? Unfortunately noone of the major vendors have yet implemented MPLS control plane via IPv6 transport. From my understanding, the protocol specs are there, just no implementation

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-04 Thread devang patel
Hi, Its lab environment, just created one topology having few routers and testing it for MPLS VPN for IPv6!!! the thing is enabling MPLS on interface having IPv6 address will not bring up LDP neighbor relationship, and due to that it will not assign the MPLS label to the prefixes!!! so I just want

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-04 Thread Charles Wyble
devang patel wrote: Hi, Does any vendor support the MPLS for native IPv6 network? I was working on one testing scenario where I have Cisco 7200 routers and whole network is running only IPv6 and I wanted to run MPLS on the top of that but I found MPLS is not supported on IPv6 networks? is that t

Re: MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-04 Thread Charles Wyble
devang patel wrote: Hi, Does any vendor support the MPLS for native IPv6 network? I think the bigger question is what vendors support native IPv6 networks and at what stage of maturity. :) I was working on one testing scenario where I have Cisco 7200 routers and whole network is running

MPLS for IPv6

2008-11-04 Thread devang patel
Hi, Does any vendor support the MPLS for native IPv6 network? I was working on one testing scenario where I have Cisco 7200 routers and whole network is running only IPv6 and I wanted to run MPLS on the top of that but I found MPLS is not supported on IPv6 networks? is that true? regards Devang P