Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-28 Thread Mike Leber via NANOG
Here's a related good article: "Excessive BGP AS-PATH prepending is a self-inflicted vulnerability" https://blog.apnic.net/2019/07/15/excessive-bgp-as-path-prepending-is-a-self-inflicted-vulnerability/ You probably should not use a limit greater than 50 unless you want to encourage this behavi

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-27 Thread Tom Beecher
Yeah,I meant RIB, not FIB. Should have finished coffee first. :) On Fri, Aug 26, 2022 at 9:10 PM Lincoln Dale wrote: > If I was running an edge device with a limited FIB, perhaps I might drop >> it to save memory. If I had beefier devices, perhaps I would just depref >> it. >> > > Note that if s

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-26 Thread William Herrin
On Thu, Aug 25, 2022 at 10:58 AM Tom Beecher wrote: > If I was running an edge device with a limited FIB, perhaps >I might drop it to save memory. If I had beefier devices, perhaps >I would just depref it. Hi Tom, Neither of these answers make much sense to me. If you're using a default route to

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-26 Thread Lincoln Dale
> > If I was running an edge device with a limited FIB, perhaps I might drop > it to save memory. If I had beefier devices, perhaps I would just depref > it. > Note that if said prefix either existed elsewhere with fewer prepends that meant it 'won' bgp best-path selection, then it would not resul

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-25 Thread Jeff Tantsura
https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-ietf-grow-as-path-prepending Cheers, Jeff > On Aug 25, 2022, at 11:00, Tom Beecher wrote: > >  > >> Usually What shoud we do ? Should we filter it ? > > > As with many things, the answer depends on your situation. > > If I was running an edge de

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-25 Thread Tom Beecher
> Usually What shoud we do ? Should we filter it ? > As with many things, the answer depends on your situation. If I was running an edge device with a limited FIB, perhaps I might drop it to save memory. If I had beefier devices, perhaps I would just depref it. Maybe it's a prefix/source ASN I h

Re: [External] Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-25 Thread Hunter Fuller via NANOG
I would imagine the "long as-path" one would handle excessive prepends too, right? 50 prepends is silly but doesn't really hurt my feelings. But >100 is absurd. -- Hunter Fuller (they) Router Jockey VBH M-1C +1 256 824 5331 Office of Information Technology The University of Alabama in Huntsville

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-25 Thread Alejandro Acosta
Hello Alistair,   Are you sure there is one about excess prepends?. I just took a look and I did not find any.   I found one about filtering long as-paths but not specifically about prepends. Thanks, Alejandro, On 25/8/22 10:31 AM, Alistair Mackenzie wrote: There are some generally acc

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-25 Thread Chriztoffer
On Thu, 25 Aug 2022, 16:31 Alistair Mackenzie, wrote: > There are some generally accepted and useful filters found at > https://bgpfilterguide.nlnog.net/. There is one which covers excess > prepends. > It's generally accepted to filter **very** long as paths. As Alistair pointed to. The guide

Re: Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-25 Thread Alistair Mackenzie
There are some generally accepted and useful filters found at https://bgpfilterguide.nlnog.net/. There is one which covers excess prepends. On Thu, 25 Aug 2022 at 15:25, anonymous wrote: > Hey everyone, > > Too many hops found as below. > Usually What shoud we do ? Should we filter it ? > > 91.2

Longest prepend( 255 times) as path found

2022-08-25 Thread anonymous
Hey everyone, Too many hops found as below. Usually What shoud we do ? Should we filter it ? 91.246.12.0/24 AS path: 4788 9002 41313 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51196 51