Re: Comprehensive community Guideline and Policies for an AS

2009-02-22 Thread Richard A Steenbergen
> nLayer's does look fairly comprehensive. > > A few nitpick that lead me to hesitate to adopt it. > > The informational tags comprised of > > 4436:TCRPP > > T The type of relationship that the route was learned through > C The continent where the route was learned > R The region where th

Re: Comprehensive community Guideline and Policies for an AS

2009-02-22 Thread Joe Maimon
Kevin Blackham wrote: See nLayer. That should be the gold standard. :) A gold standard is precisely what I am looking for. http://onesc.net/communities/as4436/ nLayer's does look fairly comprehensive. A few nitpick that lead me to hesitate to adopt it. " The informational tags comprised

Re: Comprehensive community Guideline and Policies for an AS

2009-02-21 Thread Kevin Blackham
See nLayer. That should be the gold standard. :) On 2/20/09, Joe Maimon wrote: > > > Charles Gucker wrote: >>> What I am looking for is a best practice guide on community policy setup. >>> >>> Barring that, I plan to continue examining every publicly published >>> guideline to try to produce one,

Re: Comprehensive community Guideline and Policies for an AS

2009-02-20 Thread Joe Maimon
Charles Gucker wrote: What I am looking for is a best practice guide on community policy setup. Barring that, I plan to continue examining every publicly published guideline to try to produce one, but likely as not it will suffer from the all to common human failing of shortsightedness. Feel

Re: Comprehensive community Guideline and Policies for an AS

2009-02-20 Thread Charles Gucker
> What I am looking for is a best practice guide on community policy setup. > > Barring that, I plan to continue examining every publicly published > guideline to try to produce one, but likely as not it will suffer from the > all to common human failing of shortsightedness. Feel free to look at o

Comprehensive community Guideline and Policies for an AS

2009-02-20 Thread Joe Maimon
I am looking to put together a comprehensive BGP communities guideline and policies for an AS starting from a blank slate. When I say comprehensive, I mean covers *everything* that is known to be best practice such as: Route Type Prepends Learned from Peers Learned from Peers Peers Learned fr