Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-03-01 Thread netravnen+nanog
On Mon, 27 Feb 2023 at 22:20, Jeff Tantsura wrote: > FRR hasn’t implemented RFC4364 (nor planning to my knowledge (unless someone > comes and codes it ;-)) $ grep -P -r -i 'IANA_SAFI_.* = 1\d{2,}' frr frr/lib/iana_afi.h: IANA_SAFI_MPLS_VPN = 128, frr/lib/iana_afi.h: IANA_SAFI_FLOWSPEC = 133 No

Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-03-01 Thread netravnen+nanog
On Mon, 27 Feb 2023 at 22:20, Jeff Tantsura wrote: > FRR hasn’t implemented RFC4364 (nor planning to my knowledge (unless someone > comes and codes it ;-)) $ grep -P -r -i 'IANA_SAFI_.* = 1\d{2,}' frr frr/lib/iana_afi.h: IANA_SAFI_MPLS_VPN = 128, frr/lib/iana_afi.h: IANA_SAFI_FLOWSPEC = 133 No

Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-03-01 Thread Keyur Patel
> On Feb 27, 2023, at 1:18 PM, Jeff Tantsura wrote: > > FRR hasn’t implemented RFC4364 (nor planning to my knowledge (unless someone > comes and codes it ;-)) > I believe - Arccus has implemented it (Keyur to confirm). Confirming the implementation support on ArcOS (from Arrcus). :) Best Re

Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-03-01 Thread netravnen+nanog
On Sun, 26 Feb 2023 at 21:48, Douglas Fischer wrote: > But I'm looking for an open-source engine that supports it. > > The official FRR documentation does not mention anything about RFC 4364, or > RTFilter address family. > So, I think FRR does not support RTFilter Constrained Route Distribution.

Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-03-01 Thread Chriztoffer Hansen via NANOG
On 26/02/2023 21.46, Douglas Fischer wrote: > However, I'm searching for BGP Engines that implement this address-family > (AFI=1, SAFI=132), to avoid Lock-In. > > But I'm looking for an open-source engine that supports it. rustybgp and gobgp might support it. $ grep -r -P "AFI,SAFI = 1,132" ru

Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-02-27 Thread Randy Bush
> RFC4364 ... I believe - Arccus has implemented it (Keyur to confirm) i am not keyur and do not play one on the net, but ...

Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-02-27 Thread Jeff Tantsura
FRR hasn’t implemented RFC4364 (nor planning to my knowledge (unless someone comes and codes it ;-)) I believe - Arccus has implemented it (Keyur to confirm). Cheers, Jeff > On Feb 26, 2023, at 22:58, Paul Rolland wrote: > > Hello, > >> On Sun, 26 Feb 2023 17:46:42 -0300 >> Douglas Fischer

Re: BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-02-26 Thread Paul Rolland
Hello, On Sun, 26 Feb 2023 17:46:42 -0300 Douglas Fischer wrote: > But I'm looking for an open-source engine that supports it. > > The official FRR documentation does not mention anything about RFC 4364, > or RTFilter address family. > So, I think FRR does not support RTFilter Constrained Route

BGP Engines with support to "RTFilter address-family"

2023-02-26 Thread Douglas Fischer
We are implementing an interesting L3VPN scenario for distributed DFZ on mid-size PEs. And we believe that the RT Constrained Route Distribution, RFC4684, will be ideal to solve the problems of operational levels for the intervention of configurations between PEs and Route-Reflectors. However, I'