Weekly Global IPv4 Routing Table Report

2024-10-18 Thread Routing Table Analysis Role Account
This is an automated weekly mailing describing the state of the Global IPv4 Routing Table as seen from APNIC's router in Japan. The posting is sent to APOPS, NANOG, AfNOG, SANOG, PacNOG, SAFNOG UKNOF, TZNOG, MENOG, BJNOG, SDNOG, CMNOG, LACNOG and the RIPE Routing WG. Daily listings are sent to bg

Re: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Steven Wallace
Lee, I’m attending an Internet Integrity meeting hosted by globalcyberalliance.org in a couple of weeks. I intend to discuss the topic there. I’ll also explore with MANRS if it makes sense to have recommended actions for DDoS scrubbing services. It would be great to have the DDoS providers in

Re: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Randy Bush
>> what's an as-set? > An IRR object that contains ASNs and other as-sets. Generally used to > represent a network’s customer cone. ahhh. cool. i was worried you meant {1,2,3}, which is pretty much dead. randy

Re: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Li, Weitong
We're just working on a measurement paper about this: Firstly, a measure in 2019 [1] shows that DDoS protection itself is not a major cause of RPKI Invalid (contribute less than 1%). Also, the propagation time for ROA usually takes 10 - 100 minutes, which is not that long [2]. We found out that

Re: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Steven Wallace
On 18 Oct 2024, at 13:17, Randy Bush wrote: >> In some cases, you can identify customers of DDoS mitigation services >> by looking at as-sets published by these providers > > what's an as-set? > > randy An IRR object that contains ASNs and other as-sets. Generally used to represent a network’s cu

Re: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Randy Bush
> In some cases, you can identify customers of DDoS mitigation services > by looking at as-sets published by these providers what's an as-set? randy

Re: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Steven Wallace
Hi Rich, What I see is a mix of approaches when announcing the more specific: - retaining the original origin - the origin of their upstream provider - the origin of the scrubbing provider I see no reliable way to determine which might be used. The organization creating the ROA frequently doesn

Re: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Compton, Rich via NANOG
DDoS mitigation providers normally originate a customer’s /24 or /48 with their ASN as the origin. This prefix is the most specific prefix which covers the customer’s IP(s) under attack that will be accepted on the Internet. If a customer has created ROAs for the protected prefixes, they would

RE: It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Howard, Lee via NANOG
I'm very interested in this! I'd suggest talking with the smart folks at globalcyberalliance.org, who now operate MANRS. I'm sure Brad Gorman, the ARIN product owner for routing security, is also close by. I was going to suggest an informal BoF at NANOG next week, but I see you aren't registe

It can be challenging to advise DDoS mitigation subscribers on their RPKI-ROA needs

2024-10-18 Thread Steven Wallace
DDoS mitigation services, particularly those that dynamically announce more specific routes during an attack, add complexity when advising customers on creating their RPKI-ROAs. Smaller organizations, often served by networks that provide DDoS mitigation on their behalf, might be unaware of thes