Re: [mb-style] AR philosophy

2006-05-02 Thread Brian Gurtler
Simon Reinhardt wrote: > Hi, > > I have some questions about linking philosophy which I think need to be > generally clearified because if every moderator follows their own > concepts then we don't have consistent data. > > 1. Link performers to releases: > a) always, including members of bands

Re: [mb-style] AR philosophy

2006-05-02 Thread Simon Reinhardt
mud crow wrote: 2. Link artists to releases when they performed on / wrote / engineered / otherwise worked on: a) all tracks / the whole release b) the majority of tracks c) one track and more. d) only the tracks they are credited as having worked on. Which can be very time consuming and tedi

RE: [mb-style] AR philosophy

2006-05-02 Thread mud crow
From: Simon Reinhardt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Reply-To: MusicBrainz style discussion To: MusicBrainz style discussion <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: [mb-style] AR philosophy Date: Tue, 02 May 2006 12:32:36 +0200 Hi, I have some questions about linking philosophy which I thin

Re: [mb-style] AR philosophy

2006-05-02 Thread Chris Bransden
On 02/05/06, Simon Reinhardt <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi, I have some questions about linking philosophy which I think need to be generally clearified because if every moderator follows their own concepts then we don't have consistent data. 1. Link performers to releases: a) always, includi

[mb-style] AR philosophy

2006-05-02 Thread Simon Reinhardt
Hi, I have some questions about linking philosophy which I think need to be generally clearified because if every moderator follows their own concepts then we don't have consistent data. 1. Link performers to releases: a) always, including members of bands b) only if they are guest performers