Re: Apache 2.4, AAA, Shibboleth

2020-03-06 Thread tomcat/perl
Thanks. That's an interesting idea, and I'm quite sure that we could make that work, if only as a proof of concept. The main issue I see with it, is that it would basically double a lot of our configuration sections - of which we have many - and make our configuration even more obscure than what

Re: Apache 2.4, AAA, Shibboleth

2020-03-06 Thread tomcat/perl
Genius ! Yes, I'll try that. Why did I not think of that myself ? If anything, it'll be fun to watch the log lines of authz_core and try to make sense of them. I don't even think that I have to extend our module, it should work just as well with "require UMA-user valid-user" in both cases. One

Re: Apache 2.4, AAA, Shibboleth

2020-03-06 Thread tomcat/perl
On 06.03.2020 17:18, Russell Lundberg wrote: Andy, could your custom auth handler run before Shiboleth, test for a Shiboleth token? If not present, use push_handler to run Shiboleth? If the Shiboleth token or cookie is present, don’t run Shiboleth? Well, the problem is that Shibboleth is quit

Re: Apache 2.4, AAA, Shibboleth

2020-03-06 Thread Russell Lundberg
Andy, could your custom auth handler run before Shiboleth, test for a Shiboleth token? If not present, use push_handler to run Shiboleth? If the Shiboleth token or cookie is present, don’t run Shiboleth? Russell Sent from my iPhone > On Mar 6, 2020, at 08:26, André Warnier (tomcat/perl) wrote

Apache 2.4, AAA, Shibboleth

2020-03-06 Thread tomcat/perl
Hi experts. In our Apache 2.4(+mod_perl) setups, we use the following kind of thing : ... PerlAddAuthzProvider UMA-user AUTH::UMA2->authz_user ... AuthName ALUtop AuthType shibboleth PerlSetVar UMA_AuthType "SAML2" ShibRequestSetting requireSession 1 ShibRe