Re: help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-27 Thread SJP Lists
2009/12/25 Paul M : > Here we're talking about 2 separate cases, electrical and mechanical. > > In electrical componentry, it's power up/power down that compromises the > reliability of a part (circuit). This is primarily due to heat - it's the > temperature cycling in the circuit components thats

Re: help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-24 Thread Paul M
Here we're talking about 2 separate cases, electrical and mechanical. In electrical componentry, it's power up/power down that compromises the reliability of a part (circuit). This is primarily due to heat - it's the temperature cycling in the circuit components thats the bad guy. In Mechanica

Re: help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-24 Thread frantisek holop
hmm, on Fri, Dec 25, 2009 at 10:16:28AM +1300, Paul M said that > I wouldn't think that spinning up frequently would shorten > it's life any more than if it stayed spinning. It may be very > irritating from a performance point of view though. i am no hard disk expert, but i was taught at school th

Re: help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-24 Thread Brad Tilley
On Fri, 25 Dec 2009 10:16 +1300, "Paul M" wrote: [snip] > Try a different usb enclosure. Some Seagate FreeAgent enclosures do this. Seagate forums have lots of complaints about it. Research before buying another enclosure. I purchased a FreeAgent a few years ago before this issue was well-know

Re: help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-24 Thread bofh
Small bug, potential race condition. Also may not be accurate when load is high. Change sleep 9 recommended :) :P -Tai On 12/24/09, frantisek holop wrote: > hi there, > > i have a usb external disk that spins down grotesquely > soon, 10s of inactivity sends it sleeping. hearing the > disk

Re: help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-24 Thread Paul M
I wouldn't think that spinning up frequently would shorten it's life any more than if it stayed spinning. It may be very irritating from a performance point of view though. I would think that bouncing the head round doing frequent reads/writes would be much more destructive. If one were to re-re

Re: help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-24 Thread Robert
On Thu, 24 Dec 2009 19:46:47 +0100 frantisek holop wrote: > hi there, > > i have a usb external disk that spins down grotesquely > soon, 10s of inactivity sends it sleeping. hearing the > disk spin up every time makes me think how soon it will > die if i keep this up for long. > > as atactl is

help to keep disk spinning

2009-12-24 Thread frantisek holop
hi there, i have a usb external disk that spins down grotesquely soon, 10s of inactivity sends it sleeping. hearing the disk spin up every time makes me think how soon it will die if i keep this up for long. as atactl is not working for external ata disks used through the scsi layer, i was wonde