Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-12 Thread Chris Cappuccio
Geoff Steckel [g...@oat.com] wrote: > I didn't follow the thread all the way back, so forgive me if this has > been covered. I'm betting that the disk subsystem & RAID controller > combination are choking on queued metadata writes. Some of the questions > are aimed at the user, and some at people w

Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-11 Thread Geoff Steckel
On 01/11/2012 05:12 PM, Ted Unangst wrote: On Wed, Jan 11, 2012, Chris Cappuccio wrote: If only one disk is affected at a time, 5.0 is the fastest, and has the most trouble with responsiveness while being fast, this is likely to be improved by a fair I/O scheduler. There is a generic framework

Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-11 Thread Chris Cappuccio
Ted Unangst [t...@tedunangst.com] wrote: > On Wed, Jan 11, 2012, Chris Cappuccio wrote: > > > There's also an issue with dirty buffers getting eaten up, but that is > > prominent on slow devices, and you'd be WAITing in buf_needva in that case. > > I don't think needva has been totally ruled out

Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-11 Thread Ted Unangst
On Wed, Jan 11, 2012, Chris Cappuccio wrote: > If only one disk is affected at a time, 5.0 is the fastest, and has the > most trouble with responsiveness while being fast, this is likely to be > improved by a fair I/O scheduler. There is a generic framework in place > now for schedulers to get plu

Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-11 Thread Chris Cappuccio
I think your report falls a little short on explaining the problem. It's cool to see the benchmarks improve in 5.0. But "Remarks: Terribly slow!" is all you provide to explain the problem in the same 5.0 It would be better to have another test that represents the problem along with each dd test

Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-11 Thread George Steel
I've installed OpenBSD onto this box from 4.6 through 5.0 to compare wait times for simple operations. I don't expect miracles from this relatively cheap raid controller, but, I expect it to be at least as quick as a regular sata drive! So, I'm dd'ing 10GB of zeros to a file, sleeping for a second

Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-10 Thread George Steel
Both the writing process and anything else I try to do at the same time have biowait. top itself takes several seconds to start up before I can see any output. On 10 Jan 2012, at 01:48, Chris Cappuccio wrote: > George Steel [li...@netglue.co] wrote: >> >> When writing to the disk(s), the whole sy

Re: Disk blocking and unacceptable wait times with Areca ARC 1210

2012-01-09 Thread Chris Cappuccio
George Steel [li...@netglue.co] wrote: > > When writing to the disk(s), the whole system becomes incredibly slow > until the write operation has finished. I've used dd to make 10GB files > and then timed simple operations like ls and compared this to other > OpenBSD servers I've got with single SA