Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-11-25 Thread Joao Alves
Hi Remi, Ok, thank you for the follow up. Meanwhile we have prevented it to happen by announcing the 2 OSPF routes with different metrics from hosts. This way we never have multipath triggered, and therefore, no issue. But would be great if this could be fixed, as sometimes multipath is really

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-11-23 Thread Remi Locherer
Hi Joao, just a short follow up: I can reproduce the issue with OpenBSD 6.6 and -current (from today). I could verify that it is related to the additional route with different prio. As a workaround for your prod environment you could filter this host route in bgpd. I'll look into finding a fix f

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-11-08 Thread Joao Alves
Hi Remi, Just tried with 1 FW and static route, yes it's still reproducible. The previous e-mail outputs were all related to my lab, when you see IP's like 192.168.98.x, it's lab. Regarding host1/2 interface configs: Host1: host1# more /etc/hostname.em0

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-11-05 Thread Remi Locherer
On Thu, Oct 24, 2019 at 02:09:09PM +0200, Joao Alves wrote: > Hi Remi, > > I've installed a lab with OpenBSD6.6 VM's to see if would happen in the > newer version. > > I was able to reproduce it again, but in slightly different manner. > > First of all, you need to have BGP running in FW's also,

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-25 Thread Joao Alves
Hi Remi, Ok, thank you. Best regards, João On 25.10.19 07:28, Remi Locherer wrote: > Hi Joao, > > I'll try to reproduce. It might take some time. > > Remi > > On Thu, Oct 24, 2019 at 02:09:09PM +0200, Joao Alves wrote: >> Hi Remi, >> >> I've installed a lab with OpenBSD6.6 VM's to see if woul

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-24 Thread Remi Locherer
Hi Joao, I'll try to reproduce. It might take some time. Remi On Thu, Oct 24, 2019 at 02:09:09PM +0200, Joao Alves wrote: > Hi Remi, > > I've installed a lab with OpenBSD6.6 VM's to see if would happen in the > newer version. > > I was able to reproduce it again, but in slightly different mann

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-24 Thread Joao Alves
Hi Remi, I've installed a lab with OpenBSD6.6 VM's to see if would happen in the newer version. I was able to reproduce it again, but in slightly different manner. First of all, you need to have BGP running in FW's also, and have the same route received through BGP, otherwise the issue is not re

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-23 Thread Joao Alves
Hi Remi, I've managed to fully reproduce repeatedly. So the problem is basically related with the MPATH flag. What I've done first was to force the MPATH flag to appear. To do this, I've forced both Ubuntu hosts to advertise the route simultaneously. So the first issue is at this point, whe

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-16 Thread Joao Alves
Hi Remi, Thank you very much for your time with this issue. I was afraid that you couldn't reproduce it, since I wasn't able to reproduce it anymore in that location. regarding your comment: " The result was that for a short period of time I had two fib entries for the service IP with diffe

Re: Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-15 Thread Remi Locherer
Hi João, On Thu, Oct 10, 2019 at 03:01:30PM +0200, Joao Alves wrote: > Hello OpenBSD team, > > > We are facing an issue with OSPF related routes and would like to > request your help as it seems to be a OSPF to FIB route replication issue. > > This happened already once in a different location,

Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-10 Thread Joao Alves
Hello OpenBSD team, We are facing an issue with OSPF related routes and would like to request your help as it seems to be a OSPF to FIB route replication issue. This happened already once in a different location, that one is running OpenBSD 6.3 and the site of the current report is OpenBSD 6.5

Problems with route installation to fib from OSPF

2019-10-10 Thread Joao Alves
Hello OpenBSD team, We are facing an issue with OSPF related routes and would like to request your help as it seems to be a OSPF to FIB route replication issue. This happened already once in a different location, that one is running OpenBSD 6.3 and the site of the current report is OpenBSD 6.5