Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-12-05 Thread Alexander Hall
Janne Johansson wrote: >2013/12/3 Laurent CARON > >> ** Note for future readers, don't copy and paste this config snippet >as it >> does *NOT* work as you would expect it. ** >> $PEERv6="dead:beef::1" >> $MEv6="dead:beef::2" >> > >Think of the vegans... Don't get me started on "mekmitasdigoat"..

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-12-04 Thread sven falempin
1bad::f00d On Wed, Dec 4, 2013 at 4:34 PM, Laurent CARON wrote: > On 04/12/2013 12:28, Janne Johansson wrote: > >> 2013/12/3 Laurent CARON >> >> ** Note for future readers, don't copy and paste this config snippet as >>> it >>> does *NOT* work as you would expect it. ** >>> $PEERv6="dead:beef:

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-12-04 Thread Laurent CARON
On 04/12/2013 12:28, Janne Johansson wrote: 2013/12/3 Laurent CARON ** Note for future readers, don't copy and paste this config snippet as it does *NOT* work as you would expect it. ** $PEERv6="dead:beef::1" $MEv6="dead:beef::2" Think of the vegans... dead:potatoes:burn:in:hell::1 ? ;)

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-12-04 Thread Janne Johansson
2013/12/3 Laurent CARON > ** Note for future readers, don't copy and paste this config snippet as it > does *NOT* work as you would expect it. ** > $PEERv6="dead:beef::1" > $MEv6="dead:beef::2" > Think of the vegans... -- May the most significant bit of your life be positive.

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-12-03 Thread Laurent CARON
On 03/12/2013 19:20, Andy wrote: Can you provide an example of what you did/fixed in bgpd.conf so when others google for this error they will have a pointer of what to do :) Here it is. ** Note for future readers, don't copy and paste this config snippet as it does *NOT* work as you would exp

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-12-03 Thread Andy
On Tue 03 Dec 2013 18:15:23 GMT, Laurent CARON wrote: On Mon, Nov 25, 2013 at 10:53:24PM +0100, Laurent CARON wrote: I added a new transit to my network (Level3) and this issue is back (runnning OpenBSD 5.4 but tried current also). Nov 25 22:43:55 bgpgw-002 bgpd[24271]: neighbor 2001:450:2001:1

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-12-03 Thread Laurent CARON
On Mon, Nov 25, 2013 at 10:53:24PM +0100, Laurent CARON wrote: > I added a new transit to my network (Level3) and this issue is back > (runnning OpenBSD 5.4 but tried current also). > > Nov 25 22:43:55 bgpgw-002 bgpd[24271]: neighbor 2001:450:2001:1001::45 > (ev6_gw-002_to_L3): received notificati

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2013-11-25 Thread Laurent CARON
On Wed, Oct 10, 2012 at 12:13:44PM +0200, Laurent CARON wrote: > Hi, > > I'm trying to establish a peering session with another member of an IX > (France-IX). > > On my side I do have 2 OpenBSD (OpenBGPd) boxes. (..snip..) > In my logs I do observe this: > Oct 9 09:44:40 bgpgw-003 bgpd[17498]:

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2012-10-10 Thread Laurent CARON
On 10/10/2012 20:54, Claudio Jeker wrote: Looking at the pcap I see one strange thing: 17:48:39.910152 193.105.232.181.21798 > 193.105.232.145.179: S [tcp sum ok] 35124087:35124087(0) win 16384 (DF) [tos 0xc0] [ttl 1] (id 53673, len 48) 17:48:39.910198 193.105.232.145.179 > 193.105.232.181.217

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2012-10-10 Thread Claudio Jeker
On Wed, Oct 10, 2012 at 05:51:38PM +0200, Laurent CARON wrote: > On 10/10/2012 16:40, Simon Perreault wrote: > >What versions? > > OpenBSD 5.1 (sorry for not mentionning it). > > > > >>In my logs I do observe this: > > > >A pcap dump would be useful... > > Here it is: > http://elfe.lncsa.com/get

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2012-10-10 Thread Laurent CARON
On 10/10/2012 18:12, Simon Perreault wrote: The pcap shows that the Cisco box is refusing your OPEN message. It doesn't like it for some reason. You need to figure out why. Probably because of the way it's configured. I see no reason to blame either side so far. I've gotten the config on the ci

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2012-10-10 Thread Simon Perreault
Le 2012-10-10 11:51, Laurent CARON a écrit : A pcap dump would be useful... Here it is: http://elfe.lncsa.com/get?k=5Rya5Acaq26TqJ9MXG The pcap shows that the Cisco box is refusing your OPEN message. It doesn't like it for some reason. You need to figure out why. Probably because of the way

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2012-10-10 Thread Laurent CARON
On 10/10/2012 16:40, Simon Perreault wrote: What versions? OpenBSD 5.1 (sorry for not mentionning it). In my logs I do observe this: A pcap dump would be useful... Here it is: http://elfe.lncsa.com/get?k=5Rya5Acaq26TqJ9MXG FYI, subcode 8 has not yet been assigned by IANA: http://www.i

Re: [OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2012-10-10 Thread Simon Perreault
Le 2012-10-10 06:13, Laurent CARON a écrit : On my side I do have 2 OpenBSD (OpenBGPd) boxes. What versions? In my logs I do observe this: A pcap dump would be useful... Oct 9 09:44:40 bgpgw-003 bgpd[17498]: neighbor 193.105.232.181 (pv4_gw-003_to_ISC): state change Idle -> Connect, rea

[OpenBGPd <=> Cisco] error in OPEN message, unknown subcode 8

2012-10-10 Thread Laurent CARON
Hi, I'm trying to establish a peering session with another member of an IX (France-IX). On my side I do have 2 OpenBSD (OpenBGPd) boxes. Config: group "peering" { holdtime30 holdtime min3 announceself set med