Re: Moving amber into separate repo?

2022-09-24 Thread Eric Engestrom
Hi Filip! Others have what explained why copying the repo (and everything around it) is not a good idea, so I'll only reply to the other points. On 2022-09-22 at 22:37 UTC+02:00, Filip Gawin wrote: > Hi, recently I've seen case of user been using Amber when hardware was > supported by mainline

Re: Moving amber into separate repo?

2022-09-24 Thread Yonggang Luo
Currently, amber branch only have * radeon * r200 * i915 * i965 * nouveau (the DRI driver for NV04-NV20) Indeed, I think i915 and i965 can also be removed from amber branch, because they have alternative i915g/ crocus alternatives in main branch, maybe in future, after all code that's not belongs

Re: Moving amber into separate repo?

2022-09-24 Thread Jason Ekstrand
On September 24, 2022 04:04:48 "Filip Gawin" wrote: 2. repo is growing large. Amber kinda requires long history, modern mesa not. This may be good spot to split if cleanup is required. mesa absolutely uses long history. there is nothing to clean up. those bytes of disk space are well wort

Re: Moving amber into separate repo?

2022-09-24 Thread Filip Gawin
> 2. repo is growing large. Amber kinda requires long history, modern > mesa not. This may be good spot to split if cleanup is required. mesa absolutely uses long history. there is nothing to clean up. those bytes of disk space are well worth it. (Neutral on the other points, I don't work on stu

Re: Moving amber into separate repo?

2022-09-24 Thread Marek Olšák
Removing mainline drivers from the build system of Amber is a good idea. Marek On Fri, Sep 23, 2022, 06:33 Filip Gawin wrote: > Hi, recently I've seen case of user been using Amber when hardware was > supported by mainline mesa. This gave me a couple of thoughts. > > 1) Users don't correlate "A

Re: Moving amber into separate repo?

2022-09-24 Thread Marek Olšák
Git stores all commits. Removing files at the top of main doesn't make the repository smaller. It actually makes it bigger. Forking the repository would also double the size on the server. Marek On Fri, Sep 23, 2022, 06:33 Filip Gawin wrote: > Hi, recently I've seen case of user been using Ambe