Re: [mailop] Gmail & TLS SNI {dkim-fail}

2018-04-16 Thread Phil Pennock
On 2018-04-16 at 11:45 -0700, Ned Freed wrote: > AFAIK this does not happen in MTA-STS, that is, at no time is the MX hostname > obtained from the DNS checked against the "mx" list from the MTA-STS policy. > Rather, the DNS-ID of the certificate returned by the server is checked > against > the "m

Re: [mailop] Gmail & TLS SNI {dkim-fail}

2018-04-16 Thread Ned Freed
> In MX delivery without DNSSEC, if Eve injects an MX record: > gmail.com. IN MX 1 my-spy-agency.example.org. > then using the hostname from DNS means that the client will happily go > talk to my-spy-agency.example.org, using that as the SNI, and validating > against that same domain, then pres