[Fwd: Re: feature request: named sessions]

2009-02-21 Thread Manoj Rajagopalan
Forwarding to lyx-devel... Original Message Subject: Re: feature request: named sessions Date: Fri, 20 Feb 2009 13:39:10 +0100 From: G. Milde To: Manoj Rajagopalan On 19.02.09, Manoj Rajagopalan wrote: Guenter Milde wrote: * implement as separate app and use the

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-20 Thread Richard Heck
Pavel Sanda wrote: Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: The feedback I've received is equally in favor of top-level vs. nesting within File. How do you developers decide which way to go in such cases? it usually leads to flamewar without reaching anywhere :) The menu stuff is the

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-20 Thread Pavel Sanda
Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: > >The feedback I've received is equally in favor of top-level vs. > >nesting within File. How do you developers decide which way to > >go in such cases? it usually leads to flamewar without reaching anywhere :) > According to my count it's 2-2 (including you).

RE: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-20 Thread Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW
>A top-level menu item seemed justified because: > >(a) Sessions are not really files - Windows are neither, exiting isn't ... >(b) There are enough session-related operations to warrant >a separate menu-group That's what I doubted, but let's see what you'll come up with. >(c) KATE uses a t

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-19 Thread Manoj Rajagopalan
Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: Is it really necessary to have a new top level menu item ? Giving a name to a session could be done when saving, loading sessions could be done with the same File->Open dialog and File->Recent items. Then we only need to add to the File menu would be "Sa

RE: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-19 Thread Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW
>It's disconcerting to have a window with 3 tabs in it and to try >(with the keyboard) to cycle around these tabs only to find more >tabs being added to that window for documents that are displayed >only in other windows. (Is that description clear? ... Is that a >problem for platforms other than

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-19 Thread Bennett Helm
On Thu, Feb 19, 2009 at 9:50 AM, rgheck wrote: > Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: >> >> >>> >>> I have started a wiki page to maintain an informal spec: >>> >>> http://wiki.lyx.org/Devel/NamedSessions >>> >>> Please examine/edit to offer your suggestions. I've tagged >>> it with [[!LyX 2_0]] th

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-19 Thread rgheck
Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: I have started a wiki page to maintain an informal spec: http://wiki.lyx.org/Devel/NamedSessions Please examine/edit to offer your suggestions. I've tagged it with [[!LyX 2_0]] though I don't know when v2.0 >is slated for release - I didn't see anyone us

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-19 Thread Guenter Milde
On 2009-02-18, Manoj Rajagopalan wrote: > I have started a wiki page to maintain an informal spec: > http://wiki.lyx.org/Devel/NamedSessions > Please examine/edit to offer your suggestions. I added two alternative suggestions: * implement as separate app and use the lyxserver. (I can open ly

RE: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-18 Thread Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW
>I have started a wiki page to maintain an informal spec: > >http://wiki.lyx.org/Devel/NamedSessions > >Please examine/edit to offer your suggestions. I've tagged >it with [[!LyX 2_0]] though I don't know when v2.0 >is slated >for release - I didn't see anyone use tags > 2_0 Is it really necess

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-18 Thread Manoj Rajagopalan
Great! :-) I have started a wiki page to maintain an informal spec: http://wiki.lyx.org/Devel/NamedSessions Please examine/edit to offer your suggestions. I've tagged it with [[!LyX 2_0]] though I don't know when v2.0 is slated for release - I didn't see anyone use tags > 2_0 thanks, Manoj

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-18 Thread Abdelrazak Younes
Manoj Rajagopalan wrote: From your description, it seems you are referring to the QSettings class for storing info about open files etc. Yes, right. Sorry about the confusion. If this is the case, sorry I didn't make the connection to the Qt SMF earlier - while their functionality overlaps,

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-18 Thread Manoj Rajagopalan
Hi Abdel, Vincent, Richard and other developers, Abdel, Could you be a little more detailed in how you think we could bring in the session framework? From what I understand, the session management framework (SMF) allows us to enter some state parameters as hooks which are called by the d

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-16 Thread Vincent van Ravesteijn
rgheck schreef: Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: You want to make a LyX session file to manage master and child documents. However, as it is now, all child and master documents are loaded when loading a child or master document. This basically means that we already have the possibility to op

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-16 Thread rgheck
Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: You want to make a LyX session file to manage master and child documents. However, as it is now, all child and master documents are loaded when loading a child or master document. This basically means that we already have the possibility to open a set of files

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-16 Thread Abdelrazak Younes
Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW wrote: IIUC we should be careful to distinguish the application session from the document session. The LyX application is a part of the windows/ linux/mac desktop and is handed a session manager from the desktop overlord for clean startup and shutdown. But for na

RE: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-16 Thread Vincent van Ravesteijn - TNW
>IIUC we should be careful to distinguish the application session from >the document session. The LyX application is a part of the windows/ >linux/mac desktop and is handed a session manager from the desktop >overlord for clean startup and shutdown. But for named document >sessions, LyX plays the

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-13 Thread Manoj Rajagopalan
Abdelrazak Younes wrote: Richard Heck wrote: Manoj Rajagopalan wrote: Hi dev group, Sometime ago, I'd filed a feature request for supporting named sessions in LyX: http://bugzilla.lyx.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5551 I'd like to enquire if someone is already working on that or if I could gi

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-13 Thread Abdelrazak Younes
Richard Heck wrote: Manoj Rajagopalan wrote: Hi dev group, Sometime ago, I'd filed a feature request for supporting named sessions in LyX: http://bugzilla.lyx.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5551 I'd like to enquire if someone is already working on that or if I could give this a shot. There seems

Re: feature request: named sessions

2009-02-13 Thread Richard Heck
Manoj Rajagopalan wrote: Hi dev group, Sometime ago, I'd filed a feature request for supporting named sessions in LyX: http://bugzilla.lyx.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5551 I'd like to enquire if someone is already working on that or if I could give this a shot. There seems to be a Session clas