Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Ivan Reche
2012/2/9 Thomas Lange > > On Thu, 9 Feb 2012 12:59:03 -0200, Ivan Reche > said: > > >> Oh, I just forgot to mention another doubt: >> - when I ssh into a system that has just been installed and waiting > for reboot, I can see a lot of >> FAI's variables, but $SERVER doesn't show

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Thomas Lange
> On Thu, 9 Feb 2012 12:59:03 -0200, Ivan Reche said: > Oh, I just forgot to mention another doubt: >  - when I ssh into a system that has just been installed and waiting for reboot, I can see a lot of > FAI's variables, but $SERVER doesn't show anything and there isn't any var

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Ivan Reche
2012/2/9 Ivan Reche > 2012/2/9 Thomas Neumann > >> >> +It is possible to remotely execute 'fai-chboot ...' on the fai >> >> server to switch the installed client to localboot after the >> >> installation has completed. Warning: This may open up the fai >> >> installation environment to exploits

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Ivan Reche
2012/2/9 Thomas Neumann > >> +It is possible to remotely execute 'fai-chboot ...' on the fai > >> server to switch the installed client to localboot after the > >> installation has completed. Warning: This may open up the fai > >> installation environment to exploits if the remote login account >

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Thomas Lange
> On Thu, 9 Feb 2012 15:11:29 +0100, "Thomas Neumann" > said: First, I didn't hat the impression that anyone wants to attack me. > That's totally fine. But why isn't that part of the documentation? Why not > state that there are architectural issues related to pxe, tftp and

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Thomas Neumann
>> +It is possible to remotely execute 'fai-chboot ...' on the fai >> server to switch the installed client to localboot after the >> installation has completed. Warning: This may open up the fai >> installation environment to exploits if the remote login account >> is not properly secured. > Sorr

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Carsten Aulbert
Hi Am 2012-02-09 16:11, schrieb Thomas Neumann: -To skip booting from network card, you can use the command fai-chboot(8) to enable localboot. +It is possible to remotely execute 'fai-chboot ...' on the fai server to switch the installed client to localboot after the installation has comple

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Thomas Neumann
> Any kind of automated installation is unsecure. [...] [...] > Since PXE (and tftp) is insecure, FAI does not have special options for > making completely insecure things more secure. That's totally fine. But why isn't that part of the documentation? Why not state that there are architectural iss

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Michał Dwużnik
Hi Thomas, > I apologize with all sincerence if you had the impression I'm trying to > attack you. I didn't intend to at all. > Apologies if I overreacted, too. I find it very useful to talk about vulnerabilities, sorry that particular phrasing of 'Does nobody see the fault in...' made me read '

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Thomas Neumann
I apologize with all sincerence if you had the impression I'm trying to attack you. I didn't intend to at all. > I don't see big flashing 'thou are forbidden to harden your install as > you see fit' in the manpage either. No. There isn't. I wrote this reply, because on the outside it _seems_ ssh+

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Thomas Lange
> On Thu, 9 Feb 2012 10:41:26 +0100, "Thomas Neumann" > said: > Does nobody see the fault in having > - a NFS-share mountable by any client [on a specific network] > - a SSH-Key without a passphrase stored in that NFS-share > - a login account allowing (at least) the

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Michał Dwużnik
Hi Thomas, On Thu, Feb 9, 2012 at 10:41, Thomas Neumann wrote: > Please note: I haven't used fai-chboot to automatically disable > fai-installation yet because the manpage scares me too much. What is > described in this mail is an attack scenario that seems to be possible > judging from the manpa

Re: How to prevent new installations when I have already installed my client through LAN boot?

2012-02-09 Diskussionsfäden Thomas Neumann
Please note: I haven't used fai-chboot to automatically disable fai-installation yet because the manpage scares me too much. What is described in this mail is an attack scenario that seems to be possible judging from the manpage. > have a look there: > https://lists.uni-koeln.de/pipermail/linux-fa