Re: ottava spanner terminates at the end of the note, not the end of the bar

2022-05-14 Thread Valentin Petzel
Hi Ken, I'd argue that being a professional composer does not imply being versed in musical typesetting (similar to how most professional writers do know little about typesetting). In fact I'd say many professional composers want to spend their time composing and getting their compositions per

Re: ottava spanner terminates at the end of the note, not the end of the bar

2022-05-14 Thread Kenneth Wolcott
Hi Valentin; Thank you for your insights. I think I'll just drop this attempt to reproduce exactly what the last transcriber/arranger tried to accomplish (even though the person in question is an established modern day composer, David Bruce). I appreciate both you and Aaron sharing your expe

Re: ottava spanner terminates at the end of the note, not the end of the bar

2022-05-14 Thread Kenneth Wolcott
Thank you, Aaron. Interesting thoughts... Ken On Fri, May 13, 2022 at 9:21 PM Aaron Hill wrote: > > On 2022-05-13 8:28 pm, Kenneth Wolcott wrote: > > The ottava spanner terminates at the end of the note, not at the end > > of the bar. > > > > How to change this? > > > > Screenshots attach

Re: ottava spanner terminates at the end of the note, not the end of the bar

2022-05-14 Thread Valentin Petzel
Hello Ken, As far as I know Lilypond's behaviour here is pretty much the standard behaviour, as done by most Software, Editions and recommended by Gould. Thus doing ottava markings like this should be considered uncommon notation. Considering Tchaikovsky is not exactly modern music I think it i

Re: ottava spanner terminates at the end of the note, not the end of the bar

2022-05-13 Thread Aaron Hill
On 2022-05-13 8:28 pm, Kenneth Wolcott wrote: The ottava spanner terminates at the end of the note, not at the end of the bar. How to change this? Screenshots attached. Consider the following: \version "2.22.0" \relative c'' { % Be careful not to stop the ottava too soon. \ot