Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread David Kastrup
Marc Hohl writes: > Ok, let's take the guitar string bend stuff as an example: I think > that Lilypond would benefit *a lot* if this feature were implemented. > Tuxguitar can export .ly files, but without the bend stuff. > > A skilled programmer should be able to implement this for, say, 300$. >

Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread David Kastrup
Tim McNamara writes: > As a user, I would tend to prefer to just kick money into a general > fund and let someone figure out how it gets utilized for exactly the > reason that was mentioned: I might want feature X, but groundwork U V > and W- about which I know nothing- would have to precede the

Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread David Kastrup
Tim McNamara writes: > It is quite possible that the Lilypond team doesn't want to have to > set up accounting and disbursement mechanisms, however. There are > some headaches and legalities that would be involved which might be > more trouble than they are worth. That is the current problem.

Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread Tim McNamara
On Jan 25, 2012, at 2:48 AM, Marc Hohl wrote: > Am 25.01.2012 02:06, schrieb Tim McNamara: >> As a user, I would tend to prefer to just kick money into a general fund and >> let someone figure out how it gets utilized for exactly the reason that was >> mentioned: I might want feature X, but gr

Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread Marc Hohl
Am 25.01.2012 11:01, schrieb David Kastrup: Marc Hohl writes: [...] I don't know about legal and organizational issues, but what about a optional lilypond usage fee? "fee" has a bad ring to it. Ok, this was not the appropriate word - replace it with whatever you think is reasonable. We are

Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread David Kastrup
Marc Hohl writes: > Am 25.01.2012 02:06, schrieb Tim McNamara: >> As a user, I would tend to prefer to just kick money into a general > fund and let someone figure out how it gets utilized for exactly the > reason that was mentioned: I might want feature X, but groundwork U V > and W- about which

Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread Shevek
Marc Hohl wrote: > > > I don't know about legal and organizational issues, but what about a > optional lilypond usage fee? > I am willing to pay about 50$ per year for using lilypond and supporting > the development team. > And I think there are some more users out therewho would join ... >

Re: Bounties

2012-01-25 Thread Marc Hohl
Am 25.01.2012 02:06, schrieb Tim McNamara: As a user, I would tend to prefer to just kick money into a general fund and let someone figure out how it gets utilized for exactly the reason that was mentioned: I might want feature X, but groundwork U V and W- about which I know nothing- would ha

Re: Bounties

2012-01-24 Thread Tim McNamara
As a user, I would tend to prefer to just kick money into a general fund and let someone figure out how it gets utilized for exactly the reason that was mentioned: I might want feature X, but groundwork U V and W- about which I know nothing- would have to precede the addition of feature X. Bou

Re: Bounties

2012-01-24 Thread David Kastrup
Janek Warchoł writes: > I think that bounties will never have significant impact on Lily > development if we don't organize them. It's because writing code is > very expensive ($200-500 for a nontrivial patch?) compared to money > average user can spend (few can afford $100 i think). > I am seri

Re: bounties

2010-06-20 Thread Bernardo Barros
The donation idea is pretty good. That't pretty ok with GNU philosophy BTW. Think of the Free Software Foundation. Ardour has a way of doing this, it has one main developers and it seems that who contribute more to the project have more priority in the suggestion of requested features. Of course c

Re: bounties

2010-06-20 Thread Joseph Wakeling
On 06/17/2010 03:35 PM, Valentin Villenave wrote: > The main obstacle, of course, being the international essence of the > project, whereas non-profit organisations, bank accounts, etc. are > usually conceived in a nation-centric perspective. What are the particular problems there? Is it just thi

Re: bounties

2010-06-18 Thread Jan Nieuwenhuizen
Op donderdag 17-06-2010 om 15:35 uur [tijdzone +0200], schreef Valentin Villenave: > As I mentioned in the other thread, there are plans to build such an > organization in France, from scratch (another possibility would be to > revive the (Netherlands-based?) LilyPond foundation, but we'd need > m

Re: bounties

2010-06-17 Thread Xavier Scheuer
2010/6/17 Valentin Villenave : > Absolutely. That's why I've always said that we should have something > like a "bounty thermometer" (such as the one they use for Blender's > open movies IIRC, or http://haikuware.com/bounties/ as well). Agree. At this time there is nothing on the official LilyPon

Re: bounties

2010-06-17 Thread Editions IN NOMINE
so +1 The question is : how is it used, what for, and by who ? It may sound an odd question, but I can assure you that in France, such questions of transparency ARE NOT that obvious. I think each list shouild have its contributors ? Cheers JM Marek Klein a écrit : 2010/6/17 Christ van Wil

Re: bounties

2010-06-17 Thread Marek Klein
2010/6/17 Christ van Willegen > On Thu, Jun 17, 2010 at 6:24 PM, David Stocker > wrote: > > I think > > LilyPond has a dedicated base of users who would be glad to contribute > > resources in a concrete and structured way. It might be worth > considering. > > I agree. Paying a 'subscription' for

Re: bounties

2010-06-17 Thread Christ van Willegen
On Thu, Jun 17, 2010 at 6:24 PM, David Stocker wrote: > I think > LilyPond has a dedicated base of users who would be glad to contribute > resources in a concrete and structured way. It might be worth considering. I agree. Paying a 'subscription' for Lilypond usage would suit me just fine. Chris

Re: bounties

2010-06-17 Thread David Stocker
If you haven't already, have a look at Ardour's subscription page http://ardour.org/why_subscribe This may be a viable answer. At one time, I was a subscriber, contributing $4.00US per month via automated paypal withdrawl. $4.00/mo is pretty painless when you lump it in with your other busines

Re: bounties

2010-06-17 Thread Editions IN NOMINE
Hi. I thought one could order "pieces of improvment" (it's been a long time since I read something on it...). The idea is : I pay for my personnel need, and the improvment is put back in the community. This question strikes me because I've just beginning to set up shop as an editor, and I've

Re: bounties

2010-06-17 Thread Valentin Villenave
On Thu, Jun 17, 2010 at 8:38 AM, Marc Hohl wrote: > (I wouldn't surely be the ideal person for founding a lilypond > users group), I am willing to spend a fee, say $50 a year, for > supporting the lilypond development. If there are 99 people more > (and I think there are a lot more!), we would hav

Re: bounties

2010-06-16 Thread Marc Hohl
Jonathan Wilkes schrieb: Writing reports on deliverables isn't overhead, it's documentation of new features (which would have to be done anyway). Though presentations would certainly be overhead, as well as filling out forms, forms, forms... [...] On Tue, Jun 15, 2010 at 08:25:27PM +0200,

Re: bounties

2010-06-15 Thread Jonathan Wilkes
Writing reports on deliverables isn't overhead, it's documentation of new features (which would have to be done anyway).  Though presentations would certainly be overhead, as well as filling out forms, forms, forms... -Jonathan Message: 2 Date: Tue, 15 Jun 2010 20:19:34 +0100 From: Graham Per