Re: Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread David Kastrup
mclaren writes: > Hans; Hans being short for "Urs" or assigning a common name to a group of people? > You mentioned: > "LilyPond doesn't require all the barlines to align in order to be able > to break a line, it only requires an arbitrary *moment* to align. If you > have such a moment you can

Re: Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> A meter of 7/sqr(71) [...] > The problem comes from Lilypond's bizarre assumption that at some > point all the barlines in the score will line up. [...] > > That's a) insane, Mhmm. > b) stupid, Mhmm, mhmm. > c) unmusical, You are joking, aren't you? Show me *any* piece that uses this – e

Re: Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread Urs Liska
Am 04.11.2016 um 03:29 schrieb mclaren: > Hans; > > You mentioned: > "LilyPond doesn't require all the barlines to align in order to be able > to break a line, it only requires an arbitrary *moment* to align. If you > have such a moment you can break lines, and the manual tells you how to > achie

Re: Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread mclaren
Hans; You mentioned: "LilyPond doesn't require all the barlines to align in order to be able to break a line, it only requires an arbitrary *moment* to align. If you have such a moment you can break lines, and the manual tells you how to achieve that." Sorry, no, the Lilypond manual does _not_ te

Re: Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread Nathan Ho
On 2016-11-03 17:36, mclaren wrote: The problem comes from Lilypond's bizarre assumption that at some point all the barlines in the score will line up. In this case, clearly the barlines in the 7/sqr(71) staff will never line up with any of the other barlines in the score. Therefore Lilypond c

Re: Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread Urs Liska
Am 04.11.2016 um 01:36 schrieb mclaren: > A meter of 7/sqr(71) simply means that that there are 7 eighth notes each of > which has duration of square root of 71 = 1/8.426149 of a whole note, > whereas a standard eighth note has duration of 1/8 of a whole note. > Therefore each eighth note in 7/sq

Re: Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread Urs Liska
Am 04.11.2016 um 01:36 schrieb mclaren: > Therefore Lilypond can't ever break the page. > > That's a) insane, b) stupid, c) unmusical, d) all three (take your pick). Before I may try to understand the case (particularly as your questions so far indicated that you may not always have really read

Can't get page breaks for 7 over square root of 71 meter

2016-11-03 Thread mclaren
A meter of 7/sqr(71) simply means that that there are 7 eighth notes each of which has duration of square root of 71 = 1/8.426149 of a whole note, whereas a standard eighth note has duration of 1/8 of a whole note. Therefore each eighth note in 7/sqr(71) meter has a duration of 8.426149/8 = 1.0532