Re: Chord naming conventions (was: triangle chord notation)

2006-08-12 Thread Andre Schnoor
Paul Scott wrote: Andre Schnoor wrote: Er, no. These are three distinctive chords: Xdim = 1, b3, b5 Xm.dim7= 1, b3, b5, b7 Xdim7= 1, 3, b5, b7 One may argue that "m.dim7" is a weird exception in that is uses that fancy dot. Alternatively "X(b5,b7)" w

Re: Chord naming conventions (was: triangle chord notation)

2006-08-12 Thread Andre Schnoor
rds, I would go with dim dim7 C Eb Gb A (Bbb) instead of m.dim7 unless you are wanting to spell C Eb G A -Original Message----- From: Andre Schnoor <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Aug 8, 2006 1:54 PM To: lilypond-user@gnu.org Subject: Chord naming conven

Re: triangle chord notation

2006-08-10 Thread Andre Schnoor
The root of a chord symbol and is related more to the the momentary tonal (key) center, not necessarily the written key signature. -Original Message- From: Andre Schnoor <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Aug 9, 2006 5:02 AM To: lilypond-user@gnu.org Subject: Re: triangle chord not

Re: triangle chord notation

2006-08-09 Thread Andre Schnoor
Michael J Millett wrote: Key signatures don't count when using chord symbols. Only for the naming of the root. There's a big difference between Ebmaj7 and D#maj7, so the root pitch should reflect its meaning within the current key. This information is valuable when looking at chord progres

Chord naming conventions (was: triangle chord notation)

2006-08-08 Thread Andre Schnoor
Maybe this could contribute to the discussion regarding chord input syntax. Below is an excerpt of chord names which are currently supported by my software Harmony Navigator. Last year I've had a fruitful discussion on rec.music.theory with Joey Goldstein. I found his suggested "standard" quite

Single vs. double angle brackets for chords with staff changes

2006-08-08 Thread Andre Schnoor
Hi all, it seems LilyPond doesn't like staff changes within a chord, since 4 doesn't work. The alternative expression <> works fine, but does no longer contain the semantics of a "chord". It could not seem to find any visual difference yet, though. What is the official recommended way

Problems with certain chord names

2006-08-05 Thread Andre Schnoor
Hi all, I'm new to this list and am currently implementing LilyPond export for my software "Music Prototyping Studio". First of all I'd like to thank the makers of LilyPond for this great and exceptional product! Most export algorithms of my program already work fine and the resulting scores