Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Werner LEMBERG
Andrew, thanks for your long reponse. I have to correct two of your statements: > But (contrary to a false statement I made about import into > Discourse) you can't import mailbox format lists into Discourse > simply, because, for example, the creation of users from 25 years > ago who most pro

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Andrew Bernard
Some final thoughts, since we are not going to do this at this point. With all the pushback I am seeing, I have little further interest in giving my time and resources to implementing this. To a certain extent I regret even bringing up the topic. People should go back and read my posts as this

Re: PNG file output

2023-02-25 Thread Jean Abou Samra
Hi, Please consider subscribing to the list (https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-user), else your messages are approved manually and you might miss a reply if the person merely replies to the list without Ccing you. Thanks. > Le 25 févr. 2023 à 18:33, jschlom...@astound.net a écri

PNG file output

2023-02-25 Thread jschlomann
Is there a way to get png output using some internal setting? #(ly: set-option 'resolution 300) works fine, but only if I use the -fpng command line option. I need to set this conditionally in the .ly file. Any way to do this? Should I be looking at guile? Thank you, John

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Michael Gerdau
Speaking up as one of the silent majority on this topic, now that it's mentioned, as I think I have two cents to add. Silent majority? I always thought and still think the Email prefering fraction to be the silent majority. But that's just my personal feeling and I do not have data to base th

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread David Kastrup
David Santamauro writes: > Since we’re airing grievances … > > The format of the response below is exactly what bothers me most about > email lists and why I favor forums. The etiquette is to quote what you > are responding to and remove everything else. Imagine 4 other people > quoted different

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> I looked up the other list that moved to Discourse (I think they had > the same Discourse/Discord confusion), but I remember that being > sold strongly on the web interface. I was certainly left with the > very strong impression email was a second class citizen. As mentioned already: The most i

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Wols Lists
On 25/02/2023 13:34, Jean Abou Samra wrote: Le samedi 25 février 2023 à 16:56 +0330, Omid Mo'menzadeh a écrit : Hi all, Speaking up as one of the silent majority on this topic, now that it's mentioned, as I think I have two cents to add. I personally wouldn't be against Discourse, as I find it

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread David Santamauro
Since we’re airing grievances … The format of the response below is exactly what bothers me most about email lists and why I favor forums. The etiquette is to quote what you are responding to and remove everything else. Imagine 4 other people quoted different parts of the original email, I now

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> Additionally, I find value in the archived aspect of web fora in > which all the discussions remain available in a very convenient > manner. If you look at the e-mail fields of any message you receive from the list, you can see the following List-Id: LilyPond user discussion List-Unsubsc

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Tim's Bitstream
  This has been a fascinating discussion bringing up many aspects I would not have thought about, having no background in mailing list administration or managing an online forum. The discussion of blocked access in some countries was eye-opening for me as I did not know that happened. Blockin

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Jean Abou Samra
Le samedi 25 février 2023 à 16:56 +0330, Omid Mo'menzadeh a écrit : > Hi all, > Speaking up as one of the silent majority on this topic, now that it's > mentioned, as I think I have two cents to add. > I personally wouldn't be against Discourse, as I find its email interface > good enough, ho

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Omid Mo'menzadeh
Hi all, Speaking up as one of the silent majority on this topic, now that it's mentioned, as I think I have two cents to add. I personally wouldn't be against Discourse, as I find its email interface good enough, however, there's something that does worry me about such a migration. As I have pointe

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Andrew Bernard
Of course it's my opinion, shared by 30,000 other communities that have selected it, which is not too bad. Anyway, we are not doing this, so further discussion is pointless. I am surprised by all the pushback. Andrew On 25/02/2023 8:51 pm, Paul Hodges wrote: I guess that's your opinion -

Re: Wondering if there's a way to not just hide N.C symbols, but have them not erase "current" chord.

2023-02-25 Thread Jean Abou Samra
Le samedi 25 février 2023 à 01:33 -0600, Matthew Probst a écrit : > Yes, you are correct.  I've not been as careful in my typing as I should be, > in my overexcitement and joy at getting a great answer so quickly.  I'll try > to compose my Emails better in the future, sorry if I offended. No pro

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Stephan Schöll
Hi Andrew, Jean Hi all (on and off thread) I have followed this thread (and its predecessor re mailing list configuration and easening admins' work) for days now. First of all: Thanks sooo much to all of you who invest hours and hours for Lilypond, the community, and all the infrastructure. It's

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Paul Hodges
From: Jean Abou Samra Did they switch from a mailing list, or from other forum/discussion software? Other forum software; e.g. Steinberg previously used phpBB which they had set up well (it's free and well-known, but a maintenance nightmare, as I know from working with it).  I've not tried

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Jean Abou Samra
Le samedi 25 février 2023 à 09:51 +, Paul Hodges a écrit : > **From: ** Andrew Bernard > > > I did a major investigation > > of other free forum programs and it pretty clear that Discourse is > > superior to all,  > > I guess that's your opinion - however, my opinion is that th

Re: Discourse

2023-02-25 Thread Paul Hodges
From: Andrew Bernard I did a major investigation of other free forum programs and it pretty clear that Discourse is superior to all,  I guess that's your opinion - however, my opinion is that the forums which I follow that have switched to Discourse are less convenient to use as a resul