Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Karl Hammar
Karl Hammar: > Neil Puttock: ... > > I basically do what Carl outlined in the other thread: > > > > make test-baseline > > > > git apply issue931041_1.diff > > > > make check > > The contributor manual says (3.6.3.1): > >* Initial test: > > make [-jX] > make test-basel

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Graham Percival
On Sun, May 16, 2010 at 4:20 PM, Neil Puttock wrote: > On 16 May 2010 16:12, Graham Percival wrote: > >> Oops, I meant to update this once it forgot. >> The diff from fixcc.py is 724 K. > > Is that with emacs 23 installed?  I seem to recall there was a wide > variation in indentation between 22 a

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Neil Puttock
On 16 May 2010 16:12, Graham Percival wrote: > Oops, I meant to update this once it forgot. > The diff from fixcc.py is 724 K. Is that with emacs 23 installed? I seem to recall there was a wide variation in indentation between 22 and 23. There are many things still wrong with fixcc.py, but it

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Graham Percival
On Sun, May 16, 2010 at 4:06 PM, Graham Percival wrote: > If anybody thinks that the first couple of items on the above list are > already done, I don't want to hear about it.  Running fixcc.py on the > /lily/ dir produces a diff that's over 100 kb; refering to this as > having our desires "pinned

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Graham Percival
On Sun, May 16, 2010 at 4:06 PM, James Lowe wrote: > Hello, > > Does that mean we need to change/edit remove something from the CG? Yes, but not from you. People who know enough about regtests that could fix that text can change this themselves. Going through a third party would only show thing

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Graham Percival
On Sun, May 16, 2010 at 4:02 PM, Neil Puttock wrote: > On 16 May 2010 14:35, Karl Hammar wrote: > >> Does it matter, if not, why is in the contributor manual ? > > I think the instructions were lifted directly from the old (2.10) > docs, so there may well have been changes to the test suite since

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread James Lowe
Hello, On 16 May 2010, at 16:02, Neil Puttock wrote: On 16 May 2010 14:35, Karl Hammar wrote: Does it matter, if not, why is in the contributor manual ? I think the instructions were lifted directly from the old (2.10) docs, so there may well have been changes to the test suite since they

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Graham Percival
On Sun, May 16, 2010 at 2:35 PM, Karl Hammar wrote: > Neil Puttock: >> > Also, it would be much easier to look throuht the patch if it did not >> > contain so many whitespace changes. In the first 100lines, I see: >> >> Why would you want to look at the bare diff? > > Isn't the diff a complete sta

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Neil Puttock
On 16 May 2010 14:35, Karl Hammar wrote: > Does it matter, if not, why is in the contributor manual ? I think the instructions were lifted directly from the old (2.10) docs, so there may well have been changes to the test suite since they were written. TBH, when I started doing regression test

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-16 Thread Karl Hammar
Neil Puttock: > On 15 May 2010 14:37, Karl Hammar wrote: > > git-pull > > wget http://codereview.appspot.com/download/issue931041_1.diff > > patch -p1 < issue931041_1.diff --dry-run > > patch -p1 < issue931041_1.diff > > make > log 2>&1; make test-redo >> log 2>&1 > > I very rarely use `make test

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-15 Thread Neil Puttock
On 15 May 2010 14:37, Karl Hammar wrote: > git-pull > wget http://codereview.appspot.com/download/issue931041_1.diff > patch -p1 < issue931041_1.diff --dry-run > patch -p1 < issue931041_1.diff > make > log 2>&1; make test-redo >> log 2>&1 I very rarely use `make test-redo'. I basically do what

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-15 Thread Karl Hammar
Neil Puttock: > On 15 May 2010 09:58, Karl Hammar wrote: > > Patching with [3] (see [2]) still gives something (see attachment) > > more like rest-2.12.png in [1], i.e. it was not fixed. > > You must've done something wrong when applying the patch/rebuilding. > > I wouldn't post a patch on Rietv

Re: Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-15 Thread Neil Puttock
On 15 May 2010 09:58, Karl Hammar wrote: > Patching with [3] (see [2]) still gives something (see attachment) > more like rest-2.12.png in [1], i.e. it was not fixed. You must've done something wrong when applying the patch/rebuilding. I wouldn't post a patch on Rietveld without first confirming

Issue 915 Multi-measure rests dependent on prefatory matter in other staves

2010-05-15 Thread Karl Hammar
Patching with [3] (see [2]) still gives something (see attachment) more like rest-2.12.png in [1], i.e. it was not fixed. The comment for the fix: Allow user override of left/right spacing of full-bar rests relative to barlines or prefatory material. implies that one has to do an override. T