Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

Alexander, Thanks a lot for the details. Antoine [image: PrestaShop] Antoine Thomas aka ttoine Developer Advocate t: +33 (0)6 63 13 79 06 antoine.tho...@prestashop.com On Wed, 19 Jun 2019

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

"Alexander, in your opinion, if the libraries are correctly used, without modifications, this ok to ship them whatever license they use? " Yes. Note that the FSF is on record supporting this view: Back in 2006 when Dan Wallace alleged in court https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wallace_v._Internationa

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

Alexander, in your opinion, if the libraries are correctly used, without modifications, this ok to ship them whatever license they use? [image: PrestaShop] Antoine Thomas aka ttoine Developer Adv

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

"A project" == https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anthology - nothing more or less than that. The issue of "compatibility" is overstated by the proponents of "strong copyleft". Just 0.2€ Am Mi., 19. Juni 2019 um 11:29 Uhr schrieb Antoine Thomas < antoine.tho...@prestashop.com>: > Patrice, > > One la

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

Patrice, One last question. You said: > the EUPL covered code is publicly available and reusable in other projects covered by OSL, GPL-2.0, GPL-3.0, LGPL etc. But what about the opposite, using OSL, GPL-2.0, GPL-3.0, LGPL etc. in a EUPL project? and then ship it? Antoine [image: PrestaShop] <

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

Dear Antoine, Providing a definitive legal answer (and certainty) in your specific case is difficult. At Joinup.eu we constantly promote interoperability and the respect of primary licences. Therefore, in our view, a global project may include components under several licences and each component sh

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

Patrice, thanks a lot for your answer. About your introduction question: the original code of PrestaShop project is currently in OSL, with some modules in AFL. We also rely on librairies in MIT and BSD, shipped with the installer (like the Symfony framework). But, we would like to use a few librai

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

Dear Antoine, It seems related to the question: how far is your project (that would be globally licensed under OSL) a derivative of the GPL-3.0 code, or not? It is also related to your legal framework, in so far the various codes are more or less closely linked. The European legal framework conside

[License-discuss] OSL and GPLv3

Hello, With our IP team, we have a few questions about compatibility between OSLv3 and GPLv3. We consider as acknowledged that it's not possible to distribute GPLv2 code in an OSLv3 project. However, what about the more recent GPLv3, considered to be more open? Of course, it's about using librair