Re: [License-discuss] [License-review] request for review of the 3D Slicer License

2021-06-09 Thread Lawrence Rosen
[Returning this to license-discuss@] Pam, you are misreading my response. If the word “agree” turns this license into a bilateral license, even then the provision is enforceable and the license is contrary to the OSD, just as a “you agree not to export contrary to US law” provision is unfort

Re: [License-discuss] [License-review] request for review of the 3D Slicer License

2021-06-08 Thread Lawrence Rosen
Hi Pam, I’m moving this to license-discuss@. If you believe that the language in the 3D Slicer license doesn't terminate the license I'd be interested in hearing how you parse the sentence. For your reference, the sentence is: "You further agree to use, reproduce, make derivative works of, d

Re: [License-discuss] [License-review] request for review of the 3D Slicer License

2021-06-08 Thread Lawrence Rosen
McCoy wrote: “FWIW, I still think these sorts of clauses are unnecessary, although unnecessary clauses aren’t themselves a violation of the OSD (if they were, well, the list would be a lot smaller 😊” I don’t think that §15 of AFL/OSL is “unnecessary.” It clarifies what is permitted (“promise