Re: [License-discuss] OSL and obfuscated code

2018-11-21 Thread David Woolley
On 21/11/2018 19:35, Mike Linksvayer wrote: I wonder whether INFOCERT's request is justifiable? I imagine they think obfuscated code is less likely to be modified, any modification potentially making the software non-compliant with the regulation, risking INFOCERT's reputation? Why isn't it g

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and obfuscated code

2018-11-21 Thread Mike Linksvayer
On Wed, Nov 21, 2018 at 4:37 PM Antoine Thomas < antoine.tho...@prestashop.com> wrote: > A new regulation which aims to fight VAT fraud obligates merchants (and > e-merchants) to use a software allowing to: > - Make accounting data inviolable, > - Secure the accounting data, > - Keep and sto

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and obfuscated code

2018-11-21 Thread Lawrence Rosen
Hi Antoine, OSL 3.0 distinguishes carefully between the original software ("Original Work" = "PrestaShop") and other software. This is why I call it friendlier than the GPL. Reciprocation (i.e., copyleft) is required for that Original Work and for its Derivative Works. Copyleft and sourc

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and obfuscated code

2018-11-21 Thread Antoine Thomas
So maybe we should wait for Larry Rosen to read and answer? Precision: the module itself would not be distributed with the PrestaShop installer. It would be available as an optional module, that users would download and install afterward. Of course, if the module is obfuscated, it is not open sou

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and obfuscated code

2018-11-21 Thread Smith, McCoy
On Wed, Nov 21, 2018 at 10:54 AM Antoine Thomas mailto:antoine.tho...@prestashop.com>> wrote: Dear Sir or Madam, I’m reaching out as Open-source Advocate for PrestaShop which is the designer and editor of an open source software solution, released under a free license (Open Software Licence OSL

Re: [License-discuss] OSL and obfuscated code

2018-11-21 Thread John Cowan
You can release it under whatever license you please, but a program released only with obfuscated source will never be an open source program, because of the Open Source Definition clause 2: 2. Source Code The program must include source code, and must allow distribution in source code as well as

[License-discuss] OSL and obfuscated code

2018-11-21 Thread Antoine Thomas
Dear Sir or Madam, I’m reaching out as Open-source Advocate for PrestaShop which is the designer and editor of an open source software solution, released under a free license (Open Software Licence OSL-3.0), allowing its users to create e-commerce websites in a quick and simplified way. A new reg