Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-20 Thread xarx
>> In my opinion, a solution similar to how eSim does that, would be completely >> sufficient for start. As I've already mentioned for several times, that's not >> much code, so it could be implemented relatively quickly. (But using eSim for >> that is not a solution, because eSim cannot fulfil the

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-17 Thread Wayne Stambaugh
ng symbols that would not be used when generating the netlist. I'm not sure I like that idea. I would have to think about that one for a while. > > * etc. > > It seems to me that some of my proposals are not in a complete alignment with > your simulations road-map. Your road-map

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-15 Thread xarx
t. * etc. It seems to me that some of my proposals are not in a complete alignment with your simulations road-map. Your road-map looks to me fit for a maximalistic solution, but I'd prefer starting with a minimalistic one. Martin. ----- Původní zpráva - Odesílatel: Wayne Stambaugh

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-13 Thread Wayne Stambaugh
On 11/12/2015 11:31 AM, x...@sms.cz wrote: > First of all, sorry for my late answer, and that I'm going to put all my > answers into a sigle e-mail. Because the public mail service I'm using had a > breakdown, was unavailable for the whole day, and the latest messages were > lost. > >> I agree wit

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-12 Thread xarx
First of all, sorry for my late answer, and that I'm going to put all my answers into a sigle e-mail. Because the public mail service I'm using had a breakdown, was unavailable for the whole day, and the latest messages were lost. > I agree with Wayne and JP, KiCAD is not designed to be a simulato

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-11 Thread Jean-Paul Louis
I am coming late in the discussion as I didn’t see the point at first. Having delt with the professional Electronic Engineering world for the past 40 years, I heard many sides of the same story. I agree with Wayne and JP, KiCAD is not designed to be a simulator, but could be a nice interface to t

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-11 Thread jp charras
Le 11/11/2015 14:35, x...@sms.cz a écrit : > Sorry, Jean-Pierre, but your answer is too vague for me. I'm just a EE > hobbyist, so I'm surely less experienced than you EE professionals. But at the > level I want to use KiCad, I don't think your points are valid. See my > comments below. First of

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-11 Thread xarx
Sorry, Jean-Pierre, but your answer is too vague for me. I'm just a EE hobbyist, so I'm surely less experienced than you EE professionals. But at the level I want to use KiCad, I don't think your points are valid. See my comments below. > > Again, we are thinking a good and strong support for si

Re: [Kicad-developers] Bug #1511552 - export of Spice net-list from EESchema

2015-11-11 Thread jp charras
Le 11/11/2015 11:26, x...@sms.cz a écrit : >>> Hopefully, if Mark Roszko implements >>> a general netlist generator he announced, the problem might >>> get resolved. >> >> I don't think Mark's changes help in this situation. Plugin or no >> plugin, you still need a way to export spice netlists. >