Re: [JPP-Devel] Edgar's CTS plugin and Bursa Wolf problems - Test

2008-05-03 Thread Edgar Soldin
hi sunburned, > The Sunburned Surveyor > I'm on the way of writing a new library for coordinate transformation, > and I'm interested by your experience, as my goal is to manage properly > 3D and grid-based transformations, not only projections and BW > transformations. > just want to remind yo

Re: [JPP-Devel] Edgar's CTS plugin and Bursa Wolf problems

2008-05-02 Thread Stefan Steiniger
So.. my two cents on the topic on European CRS. I can recommend this site that also should have some parameters for the different countries: http://crs.bkg.bund.de/crs-eu/ On the question with the warping tool. Of course, one could calculate the BW paramters. But the problem is that this would

Re: [JPP-Devel] Edgar's CTS plugin and Bursa Wolf problems - Test

2008-05-02 Thread Michael Michaud
Sunburned Surveyor a écrit : > As surveyors we always hit local control monuments to calculate a > "best fit" datum transformation. This is neede because "one size fits" > all transformations between horizontal datums in the states aren't > always precise. This is especially true when moving from h

Re: [JPP-Devel] Edgar's CTS plugin and Bursa Wolf problems - Test

2008-05-02 Thread Giuseppe Aruta
Hi Michael >.. a precision of 1-2m (5m at worst), which is not that good. >It is now recommended to use a grid to interpolate precise parameters which > makes it possible to get a precision of a few centimeters.. I am aware of this. Since my original interest was the "geological map

Re: [JPP-Devel] Edgar's CTS plugin and Bursa Wolf problems - Test

2008-05-02 Thread Sunburned Surveyor
Michael wrote: "It is now recommended to use a grid to interpolate precise parameters which makes it possible to get a precision of a few centimeters. I don't know what is the system used in USA, but I know that Canada and Australia also use grid based transformations (or corrections?) based on NTV

Re: [JPP-Devel] Edgar's CTS plugin and Bursa Wolf problems - Test

2008-05-02 Thread Michael Michaud
Hi Peppe, As you mention, bursa-wolf transformation is not always enough to make precise transformation between old local reference system and new spatial reference system. The advantage is that it relies on a set of only 7 parameters and a well known algorithm. To do more precise transformatio

Re: [JPP-Devel] Edgar's CTS plugin and Bursa Wolf problems - Test

2008-05-02 Thread Giuseppe Aruta
Hi, I did a test with the CTS plugin. As control I used Taspunto, a software for Italian coordinate transformation edited by Italian government. This software doen't use formulas for transformation but on a grid of points (1500) in the Italian territory and surroundings. It is considered to