Re: [JPP-Devel] R: R: Style Sheet For Java FOSS Coding

2008-07-02 Thread Paul Austin
Ede, I have been through this many times on commercial and other projects and have found that developers (myself included) get very upset around coding standards. I have also found that projects work much better if someone within the project makes a decision and provides a documented standard

Re: [JPP-Devel] R: R: Style Sheet For Java FOSS Coding

2008-07-02 Thread Edgar Soldin
this should read: finally I think this can go much to far, there is a potential risk to loose development capacities here, just because of indifferences about styling... keeping it balanced should be the way. regards ede -- > The important thing about using the SAME style is that if I am > ex

Re: [JPP-Devel] R: R: Style Sheet For Java FOSS Coding

2008-07-02 Thread Edgar Soldin
I agree on that ... style in terms of layout especially for easier diff detection is important.. style in terms of syntax for easier debugging. I also agree on that. But: If I decide to use ?: for my extension, people working on it _have to_ learn this perfectly legal and short statement, I am so

Re: [JPP-Devel] R: R: Style Sheet For Java FOSS Coding

2008-07-02 Thread Paul Austin
The important thing about using the SAME style is that if I am extending someone else's code in the same project (e.g. adding an additional else if clause) that when I do a diff I can see oh I just added a diff clause, rather than, oh there are abunch of whitespace changes so I really have no w

[JPP-Devel] R: R: Style Sheet For Java FOSS Coding

2008-07-02 Thread P . Rizzi Ag . Mobilità Ambiente
Yes, but I don't believe that would add anything to readability... I think the key is not about everybody using the same style, but about each one using a "consistent" style. If one always use the same style, even a non-programmer it's perfectly able of understanding it after a couple of exampl