Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-10-02 Thread Nick Stolwijk
For now we have chosen to not use the Folder plugin, but go with the Repository Server Plugin. At the moment the Maven job is good enough for us, but I guess we will move over to the Freestyle job in time. I would be very interested if the MRSP would also work for that type of job. Also, I wonder

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-30 Thread Stephen Connolly
On 30 September 2015 at 12:10, Nick Stolwijk wrote: > > For the JobDSL, we have a small department and everyone with a login can > create jobs and security is not the issue. I like the way it circumvents the > copy-paste way of maintaining jobs. > Like I said, the plugin assumes a specific securi

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-30 Thread Nick Stolwijk
That sounds like our usecase. We have a shared component-tree (ComponentA), which we use in different projects. Some of these projects depend on a released version of the ComponentA and others on a SNAPSHOT version. We are now looking for a Jenkins process, that when there is a commit to Componen

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-30 Thread Stephen Connolly
So the JobDSL plugin requires that you have a specific view on the security model of your Jenkins instance (i.e. only administrators can explicitly create/configure jobs, all other users get jobs created / updated via the JobDSL using scripts managed by administrators) A large chunk of installatio

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-30 Thread Nigel Magnay
I'll describe my use-case (which led to MRSP), and maybe that'll help. We do CI builds on every check-in (actually more complicated than that as we only have pre-tested commits). We have 'customer' projects that use these artifacts. We don't want to build the 'customer' projects at the same cade

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-29 Thread Nick Stolwijk
I'm sorry I make you feel like a sad panda. :( Would you set me on the right way as I'm just a young padawan on the road to enlightment. ;) With regards, Nick On 29 Sep 2015 22:27, "Stephen Connolly" wrote: > All this talk of the evil job type and the JobDSL plugin makes me a sad > panda. > >

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-29 Thread Stephen Connolly
All this talk of the evil job type and the JobDSL plugin makes me a sad panda. - Stephen On Tuesday, 29 September 2015, Nick Stolwijk wrote: > When you are talking about the "evil job type", do you mean the Maven > jobtype? > > I'm using those to let Jenkins find out which jobs depend on each o

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-29 Thread Nick Stolwijk
When you are talking about the "evil job type", do you mean the Maven jobtype? I'm using those to let Jenkins find out which jobs depend on each other. :S Should I reconsider my strategy? I'm currently busy to make little changes to my jobs to fulfill my needs and then automate them with the Job

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-29 Thread Nigel Magnay
It's probably what stephen says -- when I wrote the plugin was some time ago - either before (or before my awareness of) multi-branches and other non-root project types. Probably not a big fix.. It's also (currently, but am fixing) tied to the 'evil job type' :-) You might find workflow-plugin be

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-29 Thread Nick Stolwijk
Did you already check jira? Is the MRSP not used that often, and is their a better way to consume artifacts from another build? Or do we just have a strange usecase? We are switching from one big code tree to multiple subprojects and we are reorganising our Jenkins builds. Project A is going to

Re: Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-29 Thread Stephen Connolly
Looks like the repository plugin has invalid assumptions about all jobs being at the root of Jenkins. It's probably using Item.getName in place of Item.getFullName and the corresponding reverse lookups I'd check jira and if there isn't an issue already then create one. (FYI this is not an issue w

Combining Maven Repository Server Plugin and CloudBees Folders Plugin

2015-09-29 Thread Nick Stolwijk
I'm trying to use both the Maven Repository Server Plugin[1] and the CloudBees Folders Plugin[2], but I have some trouble with it. I have 2 projects, A and B, and I want the build of B to use the artifacts of a build of A. A is being triggered by a successful build of A. I also use the CFP to grou