[IPsec] Re: [CFRG] Re: Re: [IPsec]: FrodoKEM and its usage in IKemEv2

2025-01-23 Thread Michael Osborne
Hi John “My current understanding is that many European governments are planning to use FrodoKEM as the main quantum-resistant algorithm for ephemeral-ephemeral key exchange for their national security systems” This is not the sentiment that I am picking up – perhaps I speak to different gover

[IPsec] Re: [CFRG] Re: Re: [IPsec]: FrodoKEM and its usage in IKemEv2

2025-01-23 Thread John Mattsson
>There are a number of updates to government guidance in the works. I am aware and I am looking forward to these. Current public documentation and presentations from European countries has been very useful, especially documents co-authored by several countries like this https://www.forsvarsmakten

[IPsec] Re: [Schc] Fwd: WGLC for draft-ietf-ipsecme-diet-esp

2025-01-23 Thread Ana Minaburo
Dear Daniel, Thank you for sharing this work. I appreciate the thought you've put into it, and it provides us with a good starting point for further development. I have found some points for discussion 1. the Strata In your document, you need 3 strata to compress the complete stack. And anywhere i

[IPsec] CREATE_CHILD_SA in draft-kampanakis-ml-kem-ikev2

2025-01-23 Thread Rebecca Guthrie
Hello ipsecme, Regarding draft-kampanakis-ml-kem-ikev2, I am interested to know whether the following instantiation of the draft seems reasonable- it isn't explicitly provisioned for in the draft, but I don't see any issues that would prevent it from working. In a scenario where a traditional

[IPsec] Re: CREATE_CHILD_SA in draft-kampanakis-ml-kem-ikev2

2025-01-23 Thread Paul Wouters
On Thu, 23 Jan 2025, Rebecca Guthrie wrote: In a scenario where a traditional key establishment algorithm is used in IKE_SA_INIT and ML-KEM is used in IKE_INTERMEDIATE, the draft implies (but does not require) that when rekeying or creating a child SA, the traditional algorithm would be used a

[IPsec] Re: New Version Notification for draft-antony-ipsecme-iekv2-beet-mode-03.txt

2025-01-23 Thread Antony Antony
Dear WG Chairs, This is a friendly nudge for your response, as the re-chartering process seems to have progressed. Could you please let us know the next steps? Would the WG Chairs consider issuing a call for WG adoption of this document? The draft is ready to proceed, and there has been support