[IPsec] Review of draft-ietf-ipsecme-ikev2-qr-alt-04

Hi Valery, Previously, I’ve reviewed this draft before the working group adoption. I’ve reviewed the lasted version and I think it’s in the good shape. Here I have only two questions for your confirmation. 1. If the initiator proposes USE_PPK_INT in the request but the responder doesn’t includ

[IPsec] Re: Round 4 (Code-based KEMs) OFFICIAL COMMENT

Hi all, A few comments regarding the comparison below: * I see no fundamental reason to exclude FrodoKEM-AES. AES is *not* used as KDF in FrodoKEM, it is used as PRF to pseudorandomly generate the so-called *public* matrix A (for everything else it does use SHAKE). On platforms with AES ha

[IPsec] Re: Review of draft-ietf-ipsecme-ikev2-qr-alt-04

Hi William, thank you for your review. Hi Valery, Previously, I’ve reviewed this draft before the working group adoption. I’ve reviewed the lasted version and I think it’s in the good shape. Here I have only two questions for your confirmation. 1. If the initiator proposes