Re: [IPsec] ikev2bis clarification on port floating

2010-01-13 Thread Tero Kivinen
Scott C Moonen writes: > Tero, > > > > 2) Disallow floating on IKE_SA_INIT unless . . . > > Why do you want to disallow that? . . . > > > > > 3) Disallow this elective use of UDP-encap unless . . . > > Again why do that? > > I guess I'm thinking more about what is advisable (without out-of-band

Re: [IPsec] Traffic visibility - consensus call

2010-01-13 Thread Stephen Kent
At 3:02 PM +0530 1/11/10, Bhatia, Manav (Manav) wrote: Dan, You trust the end nodes to negotiate WESP and encapsulate their ESP packets in WESP but you don't trust the content they put into those packets. Is that the trust model you're operating on? No. We trust the end nodes to put th

[IPsec] Config payload text in Section 4

2010-01-13 Thread David Wierbowski
Section 4 of IKEv2bis (and RFC 4306) states: IKEv2 is designed to permit minimal implementations that can interoperate with all compliant implementations. There are a series of optional features that can easily be ignored by a particular implementation if it does not support that fea