Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] 5.0development.3 - Google Image Search 404

2015-03-12 Thread Jacob Hoffman-Andrews
Thanks Andy! I've reproduced this and am working on a fix. On 03/11/2015 05:05 PM, ANDY wrote: > MS WIN7 HP x64 > FIREFOX 36.0.1 > HTTPS-E 5.0.DEV3 > > https://www.google.com/search?q=HTTPS+EVERYWHERE&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=2NYAVdeLNJWwogTY3YDoAg&ved=0CAwQ_AUoAA&biw=1600&bih=769 > > http:/

[HTTPS-Everywhere] Automatically generated rules

2015-03-12 Thread Dominik Frühwirt
Hi, I'm currently finishing my master thesis in computer science which addresses the ruleset of HTTPS-E. Simply put, I try to generate rules for a large amount of websites automatically. Therefore, an automated browser (PhantomJS) has been utilized for fetching the HTML source of the HTTP websites

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Automatically generated rules

2015-03-12 Thread Numismatika
I do not really trust the quality of rules that were generated without any human interaction. I think the better approach is to have something like https://github.com/kevinjacobs/HTTPS-Finder/. A setting that the addon should notify you if it detects unsecured content that is available over TLS . I

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Automatically generated rules

2015-03-12 Thread Alexander Buchner
Am 12.03.2015 10:54 schrieb Numismatika: I do not really trust the quality of rules that were generated without any human interaction. I think the better approach is to have something like https://github.com/kevinjacobs/HTTPS-Finder/. A setting that the addon should notify you if it detects unsec

[HTTPS-Everywhere] Bug in development version with google

2015-03-12 Thread Alexander Buchner
I have the following problem with the newest development version: 1. Search something with google (e.g. "eff"). 2. Click on a link to an https site. 3. Nothing happens. For http sites there is no problem. And I can also open these sites in a new tab, but not in the current one. I have verified

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Automatically generated rules

2015-03-12 Thread Jacob Hoffman-Andrews
Hi Dominik! Thanks for working on HTTPS Everywhere for your master thesis. Right now my first priority for HTTPS Everywhere is to make sure it works at very high quality and doesn't break websites in any significant way. Towards that end I've been integrating automated ruleset checking written by

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Automatically generated rules

2015-03-12 Thread Maxim Nazarenko
As far as I understand, the project looks like HTTPS-Finder and https-everywhere-checker combined. Dominik, is that right? Writing rules is more art than science, I am afraid, and therefore I share Numismatika's concerns, but what is interesting is detecting whether http and https versions are esse

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Bug in development version with google

2015-03-12 Thread Jacob Hoffman-Andrews
Interesting! I can't reproduce this bug, also on Firefox 36.0.1 / Ubuntu / HTTPS Everywhere 5.0development.3. Can you open the developer panel, network tab and see if anything interesting happens there when you go through these steps? On 03/12/2015 06:06 AM, Alexander Buchner wrote: > I have the

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Automatically generated rules

2015-03-12 Thread Dominik Frühwirt
Yes, you're right, it's a kind of combination of these tools. I see your concerns about the generated rules and since you're heading towards a perfectly working ruleset I understand that you don't want them to be included. If you'd like to have the results of my evaluation of different similarity

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Bug in development version with google

2015-03-12 Thread Alexander Buchner
On 12.03.2015 19:14, Jacob Hoffman-Andrews wrote: > Interesting! I can't reproduce this bug, also on Firefox 36.0.1 / Ubuntu > / HTTPS Everywhere 5.0development.3. > > Can you open the developer panel, network tab and see if anything > interesting happens there when you go through these steps? I

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Bug in development version with google

2015-03-12 Thread Alexander Buchner
On 12.03.2015 19:14, Jacob Hoffman-Andrews wrote: > Interesting! I can't reproduce this bug, also on Firefox 36.0.1 / Ubuntu > / HTTPS Everywhere 5.0development.3. > > Can you open the developer panel, network tab and see if anything > interesting happens there when you go through these steps? I

Re: [HTTPS-Everywhere] Bug in development version with google

2015-03-12 Thread Jacob Hoffman-Andrews
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 I was just now able to reproduce: It happens on https://www.google.de/, but not https://www.google.com/. Will work on fixing. On 03/12/2015 01:29 PM, Alexander Buchner wrote: > On 12.03.2015 19:14, Jacob Hoffman-Andrews wrote: >> Interesting! I can't