Re: [hibernate-dev] Spring Cache integration

2016-11-23 Thread Steve Ebersole
I think they believe the reverse. Personally I am leery of accepting this because ultimately it is yet another piece of code we are not the experts on but will be responsible for maintaining. On Wed, Nov 23, 2016 at 1:39 AM Gunnar Morling wrote: > This is a very interesting contribution, only I

Re: [hibernate-dev] Spring Cache integration

2016-11-22 Thread Gunnar Morling
This is a very interesting contribution, only I am wondering why it should be located within the Hibernate ORM project. It seems interesting to Spring users only, so wouldn't it be better located under the Spring umbrella? --Gunnar 2016-11-22 17:50 GMT+01:00 Louis Jacomet : > Hi all, > > Can't

Re: [hibernate-dev] Spring Cache integration

2016-11-22 Thread Louis Jacomet
Hi all, Can't really say anything about the Hibernate integration, but the reason Spring caching does not implement JCache is because the abstraction is tailored at Spring integration and allows to wrap JCache into Spring Cache, because the later existed before the former. SO it would be weird to

Re: [hibernate-dev] Spring Cache integration

2016-11-22 Thread Steve Ebersole
I think this gets back to the idea we discussed when first integrating the JCache solution.. namely the idea of provisioning for these regions. At the time we concluded that it would be better to simply have the JCache integration not deal with the configuration/building of a javax.cache.CacheMana

Re: [hibernate-dev] Spring Cache integration

2016-11-21 Thread Sanne Grinovero
My initial reaction to this was of highly skeptical, as I don't see how adding layers and layers of adapters helps performance, which is crucial to the very purpose of Caching being effective. But the PR mentions interesting things; if indeed people want to use cloud service abstractions for "gene