Re: [hibernate-dev] enhancement request - relaxing theta-style joins

2007-02-16 Thread Christian Bauer
On Feb 16, 2007, at 5:56 PM, Joseph Marques wrote: What version of the ejb3 embedded container do you think this feature will make it in to? A future version. ___ hibernate-dev mailing list hibernate-dev@lists.jboss.org https://lists.jboss.org/mail

Re: [hibernate-dev] enhancement request - relaxing theta-style joins

2007-02-16 Thread Joseph Marques
Perfect! I prefer the join qualifier anyway. I just thought it might have been easier to request the relaxation of theta-style joins as it wouldn't have required any change to the query parser - just a change to how it was interpreted. What version of the ejb3 embedded container do you think

Re: [hibernate-dev] enhancement request - relaxing theta-style joins

2007-02-16 Thread Steve Ebersole
The better approach IMO is to allow more SQL-like ad hoc joining by explicitly supporting an ON join qualifier. Support for this is already being built into the redesigned query parsers. Theta-style joining went be the wayside in SQL specs for a reason ;)

[hibernate-dev] enhancement request - relaxing theta-style joins

2007-02-16 Thread Joseph Marques
From Java Persistence with Hibernate: "You probably won't need to use the theta-style joins often. Note that it's currently not possible in HQL or JPA QL to outer join two tables that don't have a mapped association -- theta-style joins are inner joins." When dealing with larger dom