Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Gunnar Morling
> Thinking about it more though, don't we have that problem anyway since we > still want to publish relocation artifacts? Do we need to create relocation artifacts for new modules only added after the group id change? There won't be wrong references to these out in the wild, so people should be fi

Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Steve Ebersole
To clarify my last reply... Today all of the artifacts under org.hibernate are published to JBoss Nexus and then rsync'ed to Central. When I move to publishing the artifacts for ORM to Central "directly" (via OSSRH), those artifacts need to be excluded from the rsync. But today, because all (mos

Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Steve Ebersole
It's more a convenience of defining the rsync that currently happens between JBoss and Central. On Wed, Oct 5, 2016, 5:48 PM Sanne Grinovero wrote: > Are we required to change groupId for that? > Asking mainly to get OGM there as well, as it's already using the proposed > scheme. > > On Wed, 5 O

Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Sanne Grinovero
Are we required to change groupId for that? Asking mainly to get OGM there as well, as it's already using the proposed scheme. On Wed, 5 Oct 2016, 23:44 Steve Ebersole, wrote: > The grouping is certainly "nice". But given the possibility of > difficulties renaming the groupId could have for use

Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Steve Ebersole
The grouping is certainly "nice". But given the possibility of difficulties renaming the groupId could have for users I'd not make this change just because it is nice. No, this is part of a larger change I want to do which is laid out in the JIRA Gunnar mentioned. Specifically I want to move awa

Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Max Rydahl Andersen
yes, with relocation artefacts things could be made less annoying. Just wanted to be sure we at least considered it and I hope you can get Gradle to play nice ;) /max > Hi Max, > > the intent is to publish "relocation artifacts" like this one which we > created when the Hibernate Search main art

[hibernate-dev] Hibernate Search: new 5.7 branch, dual streams development!

2016-10-05 Thread Sanne Grinovero
I've promoted my "ORM 5.2 upgrade preview" pull request as upstream branch "5.7", just after having it rebased on the freshly baked tag: 5.6.0.Beta3 This implies we have now two active streams of development for Hibernate Search (!); we still have just one mission: finish 5.6 and its Elasticsearch

[hibernate-dev] SQM - encoding type info into the tree

2016-10-05 Thread Steve Ebersole
In SQM's domain metamodel we decided to follow JPA's guidelines in terms of javax.persistence.metamodel.Metamodel. That is to say... a Type in SQM describes a Java type not its database mapping, just as it is in JPA. As a concrete example of the difference and its implication, consider a Boolean

Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Gunnar Morling
> On the other end, maybe grouping them together will make it clearer to > end users which artifacts need to use the same version? Right, that'd be my hope as well. It'll just more clearly emphasize which artifacts "belong together" because they are part of the same project. More fine-grained gro

Re: [hibernate-dev] Changing group ids from org.hibernate to org.hibernate.{project}

2016-10-05 Thread Sanne Grinovero
Hi Max, the intent is to publish "relocation artifacts" like this one which we created when the Hibernate Search main artifact was renamed from "org.hibernate:hibernate-search" to "org.hibernate:hibernate-search-orm" https://raw.githubusercontent.com/hibernate/hibernate-search/master/legacy/pom.x