Re: ReplicationTargetChooser has incorrect block placement comments

2013-04-04 Thread Harsh J
Hi Mei, Thanks. Please also keep hdfs-dev@hadoop.apache.org on the to: list when replying, so your questions get exposure from other HDFS devs as well :) Regarding your question, the answer is no, the NN will never violate the block placement policy on its own when choosing block location targets

Re: ReplicationTargetChooser has incorrect block placement comments

2013-04-04 Thread Harsh J
Good to know! Please also consider improving the javadoc on that method to reflect this, by logging a doc JIRA under HDFS :) On Thu, Apr 4, 2013 at 12:33 PM, Mei Long wrote: > Harsh, > > Thank you! This is exactly what I was confused about. By looking at the code > I was suspecting that it's not

Re: ReplicationTargetChooser has incorrect block placement comments

2013-04-03 Thread Harsh J
Hi Mei, These questions are best fit for the whole hdfs-dev@ group, which am adding while responding back. You're correct that the local node being not chosen, a random node on the same rack as the writer may be tried. However, if the writer node itself had no local DN in the first place, a compl